3rd Trimester

Would you ask for a new L&D nurse if you didn't like yours?

Someone was telling me the other day that if I'm "assigned" a nurse who I don't like, I should ask for a new one.  I don't know how that works in the hospital, but I'd feel like a total b*tch if I requested a new nurse.  How bad would it have to be for you to request a switch?
Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

Re: Would you ask for a new L&D nurse if you didn't like yours?

  • The nurse would have to be incompetent or rude.  I don't think I would ask for a new nurse otherwise.  
  • Loading the player...
  • Hmmm tough call. You don't want to be "that" patient, but on the other hand, labor is not easy and you don't want to make it any more difficult. I think it depends on how bad she is and how long before shift change! LOL
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagechantellio:
    The nurse would have to be incompetent or rude.  I don't think I would ask for a new nurse otherwise.  

     

    this

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • If we don't like my nurse, my doula will gladly request a new one for me or my Mom will.  I'm not worried about it.
  • My comment is coming from a nurse's perspective regarding this question.  I personally would not really worry about this.  Most labor and delivery nurses are very kind and excited to help you through your birthing experience.  Of course you will always get those few that aren't or you may have a personalty conflict and in those cases don't feel bad for asking for another nurse to provide your care.  Child birth is a special experience and you don't want it ruined by not getting along with your nurse.  It is usually best for both you and the nurse so don't feel like you are being mean.

    I am a charge nurse on my unit and I can say it is a rare occasion that our nurses don't get along well with our patients.  I can say when it does happen I have no problem giving the patient a new nurse.  

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickersImage and video hosting by TinyPicLilypie Second Birthday tickersImage and video hosting by TinyPic
  • If you aren't comfortable or don't like the nurse you could request a different one but I guess it depends on what they have for staff at the time.

    Hopefully this wont be the case for you and you have a wonderful nurse.

  • I would.  I was on hospital bed rest for a few weeks on the antepartum floor.  I had probably 20 different nurses over that time.  I liked all but one.  The one I didn't like almost gave me my procardia a few hours too early and when I told her it wasn't time, she looked at her sheet and was like, oh yeah you're right.  Also she forgot to take my vitals that night - I even called and she never showed up.  I just told someone I preferred not to have her as a nurse again and they said it wasn't a problem at all.  I felt so much more comfortable once I spoke up, not having to worry I'd have her again.  I wouldn't want a nurse I couldn't trust during labor!
    Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • I went to my L&D prep class today and they actually talked about this specificlly- she said that if you don't like your nurse, just go (or have your coach or doula go) to the nurses station, ask for the charge nurse and ask for a switch because you just are not on the same page.  Chances are, the nurse feels the same way about you.
    Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • My L&D nurse was amazing the first time around and really made the whole experience better. If the nurse was really bad this time around I would ask for a different one.
  • imagechantellio:
    The nurse would have to be incompetent or rude.  I don't think I would ask for a new nurse otherwise.  

    This.  It's my first time going through this, but based on what I've heard from all my friends who have kids, most L&D nurses are fantastic and will pretty much bend over backwards to help make you comfortable and happy.  If they weren't patient and likeable they would probably be working on a different unit that wouldn't require so much patient interaction.  I think you'll be just fine and in good hands.

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers Visit The Nest!
  • I'm surprised you can ask for a new nurse.  I don't think I can.  It seemed like when I called for a nurse, whoever wasn't that busy came in.  I think there were different nurses.  Plus all the shift changes. I guess if there were one who was right by me during the actual pushing, she'd stay there so if she was a problem I might say something.  I had amazing nurses for both deliveries.  There was one nurse overnight with DS the 2nd night who was a pain though. We are supposed to have the option of having room-in or the nursery.  I had DS go to the nursery because this was my very last chance for sleep and DD was at home.  She said she was busy and she'd let me know when someone would be there to watch him.  I reminded her once again an hour or so later. About 4 hours after that I asked someone else and she said that was weird, there were other kids in the nursery the whole time.  
  • I personally have no problem asking for a different nurse if I get one I don't jive with.  My SIL is nurse (and just had her baby) and this was one of the things she recommended to me to do if I don't feel comfortable with my assigned nurse.  She said it happens all the time, and as long as you are polite about the request, no one will think too much about it. Labor is uncomfortable enough as it is, and there's no point in making the process more stressful than what it needs to be.

  • There is a nurse at our hospital that I will refuse if she is assigned to me this time. I'm usually extra careful not to be rude, but this is one time I'm willing to make an exception. She was a mega b*tch when I was in labor with DS2 and kept telling me she just new I was going to have a c-section. Turns out, If she'd ordered my epi when the OB told her to instead of 3 hours later and the put in the catheter after the epi so DS2 could drop past my bladder I would have delivered hours earlier than I did. She kept saying that even though my OB said it was time for the epi SHE (the nurse) wanted me to progress further than the 4cm I was at before she ordered it. I will give nurses all the credit in the world for the job that they do, but this particular nurse was in the wrong for going against what my doctor ordered.

    It is your healthcare, so if you're not comfortable with a certain nurse you shouldn't feel bad asking for someone else.

  • imageacaudill042106:

    imagechantellio:
    The nurse would have to be incompetent or rude.  I don't think I would ask for a new nurse otherwise.  

     

    this

    Same here. The nurses aren't there to be our friends. They are thier to do a job so as long as she is doing it well I wouldn't ask for another nurse.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I would request a different nurse in a heartbeat.  I had the rudest, most obnoxious byatch when I was in labor with my first. She gave me nothing but attitude, then walked out during shift change when I was supposed to be pushing.

    I didn't have to say a word to anyone.  When my OB came in and found out she had left me alone for over half an hour, he went right back out the door to the charge nurse.  It's the only time in 20 years I've ever seen him angry.  

  • I would ask for a new nurse if you are uncomforatable with the one you have. My L&D nurse was downright nasty and I was in tears because of her. My DH wasn't there yet but my mom and dad were and my dad took her aside in the hallway and told her to find a replacement that was more professional. The next nurse was fantastic and very understanding (especially about the part of being in pain since I couldn't have an epi until I went into surgery).
  • unless she was completely incompetent I wouldn't.  I haven't met too many grouchy labor & delivery nurses though
    "Dear Lord, I would have loved to have held my babies on my lap and tell them about you, but since I didn't get the chance, would you please hold them on your lap and tell them about me?" DD 9/22/03 Our little sassypants! DS 4/10/10 My little man is growing so fast
  • i beg you, if you are uncomfortable with your nurse for ANY reason, have them switched.  when i had charlie, my nurse was rude, condescending, and just not nice.  i didn't want to stir the waters so i didn't say anything and i wonder to this day if i would have had a more positive experience if she hadn't been such a straigh b*tch.  really, you have the right to a positive birth experience.  it will go much more smoothly if you are comfortable with the staff. 
  • I would and have. I was able to get another nurse to talk to the charge nurse privately to get her switched. It was mostly a personality thing, but the woman inspired no confidence in me whatsoever. Coming from a stillbirth, I needed someone who at least acted competent and didn't continuously tell me how many things she was messing up.

    All of the other nurses were really great and it was not a big deal to get her switched.

  • imagechantellio:
    The nurse would have to be incompetent or rude.  I don't think I would ask for a new nurse otherwise.  

     

    This.

     

    I'm not the type of person who wants someone around to coddle me. I just want the nurse to do their job. DH will be there for my emotional support. Thats his "job." So, as long as they do their job (the medical part) and aren't treating me horribly, then I doubt I'll have a problem.

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"