What kind of crib mattress do you have?

Leelee06 · November 2009

I am wondering if the Sealy ($69) or Serta ($79) mattresses I see at Target or JCP are any good, but would love to hear what you all have. TIA!

Edit: This is the Serta mattress I saw: https://www.target.com/gp/detail.html?asin=B000S9A37I&colid=3JZNYYMHFE7PA&coliid=I2IQYZMXZ0T6BR&bckreg=baby

soon2Bmrs.AGEE · November 2009

We have a Colgate. It has a firm foam on one side for when they are babies and a softer spring on the other side for the toddler age.

KellieRay · November 2009

soon2Bmrs.AGEE:
We have a Colgate. It has a firm foam on one side for when they are babies and a softer spring on the other side for the toddler age.

Where did you get your Colgate Lindsay??

lilcrablegs · November 2009

my dh was in charge of researching this baby item so I don't know much about specifics, but we have a colgate.

aubie96 · November 2009

My nephew's is in TOP condition so my sister is giving me that for our crib.

Leelee06 · November 2009

I think I remember a few of you all saying you had Colgates... I'll do some research on them. Thx!

soon2Bmrs.AGEE · November 2009

KellieRay:

soon2Bmrs.AGEE:
We have a Colgate. It has a firm foam on one side for when they are babies and a softer spring on the other side for the toddler age.

Where did you get your Colgate Lindsay??

We got it from All About Baby.

kkh2002 · November 2009

soon2Bmrs.AGEE:
We have a Colgate. It has a firm foam on one side for when they are babies and a softer spring on the other side for the toddler age.

Ditto - we have the Classica 3 Anti-bacterial mattress. We wanted a two sided mattress (infant vs toddler) and we wanted foam rather than springs. We ordered our's from www.greatbeginningsonline.com - $150 with $6 shipping.

MrsAO · November 2009

We have the Sealy Baby Soft Premium mattress.

MissLMS · November 2009

We have a Serta crib mattress. It has worked fine.

KellieRay · November 2009

soon2Bmrs.AGEE:
KellieRay:

soon2Bmrs.AGEE:
We have a Colgate. It has a firm foam on one side for when they are babies and a softer spring on the other side for the toddler age.

Where did you get your Colgate Lindsay??

We got it from All About Baby.

I didn't know they sold mattresses! I might have to look into that!! Thanks!!!

lisap_30 · November 2009

We have the Colgate Clasica - it was rated #1 (I think) in Baby Bargains at the time - we got it online somewhere for way cheaper than we could have in a store, and with free shipping - so no matter what you get, definitely shop around.

However, s/o the Clasica - that thing is seriously as hard as a rock! I actually put J's quilt underneath her crib sheet. Also, regarding the 2 sided Clasica - the owner of the furniture place where we got J's furniture didn't recommend it, but I can't remember why. I don't recall him saying it was bad, just something @ not being worth the money.

lisap_30 · November 2009

Ah ha - here is the place we ordered the mattress from. I recall them having a lot of good deals, so you may want to check it out!

https://www.greatbeginnings.net/

Leelee06 · November 2009

lisap_30:
We have the Colgate Clasica - it was rated #1 (I think) in Baby Bargains at the time - we got it online somewhere for way cheaper than we could have in a store, and with free shipping - so no matter what you get, definitely shop around.

However, s/o the Clasica - that thing is seriously as hard as a rock! I actually put J's quilt underneath her crib sheet. Also, regarding the 2 sided Clasica - the owner of the furniture place where we got J's furniture didn't recommend it, but I can't remember why. I don't recall him saying it was bad, just something @ not being worth the money.

I picked up Baby Bargains last night and the Classica is still #1 pick. I wish I could feel these in the stores.

Leelee06 · November 2009

Thanks for all your recs!

soon2Bmrs.AGEE · November 2009

lisap_30:

We have the Colgate Clasica - it was rated #1 (I think) in Baby Bargains at the time - we got it online somewhere for way cheaper than we could have in a store, and with free shipping - so no matter what you get, definitely shop around.

However, s/o the Clasica - that thing is seriously as hard as a rock! I actually put J's quilt underneath her crib sheet. Also, regarding the 2 sided Clasica - the owner of the furniture place where we got J's furniture didn't recommend it, but I can't remember why. I don't recall him saying it was bad, just something @ not being worth the money.

We got our Colgate bc of the rating in Baby Bargains. When we bought it from the furniture store they had both the single and double sided mattress. They suggested the 2-n-1. Everything was such a blur from picking out furniture I just said ok whatever. LOL! We have since flipped it to the toddler side but I can't tell that much difference. Both sides are firmer than my mattress!

loyo03 · November 2009

I believe that ours is a Serta. We purchased it at BRUs. We have been pleased thus far. However I know that the Colgates are highly rated.

Want a personalized experience?

What kind of crib mattress do you have?

Re: What kind of crib mattress do you have?

Choose Another Board

Search Boards