Babies: 9 - 12 Months

S/O: Do kids NEED their own room?

WDYT?

DD will have her own bed and bath, but I don't think it's a necessity.

ETA:  Would you consider upgrading houses solely for this purpose?

Re: S/O: Do kids NEED their own room?

  • No, they don't NEED but it's nice to have. I always had my own room growing up and it was nice to feel like I had my own space. DS will have his own room, space allowing.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Loading the player...
  • sisters can share, and brothers can share,

    Right now my kids share, but eventually they will have their own rooms.

    My two PCOS miracles! Lilypie Kids Birthday tickersLilypie Kids Birthday tickers
  • Mo and Mae share right now, and if we aren't able to move by the time Mo's out of the crib, he'll have bunkbeds with older brother.

    I think it's nice for teenagers to have their own space, but definitely not a necessity. 

  • I missed where this is coming from - do you mean separate from siblings or separate from parents?
  • imageEcoBaby:
    I missed where this is coming from - do you mean separate from siblings or separate from parents?

    Separate from sibs.  I pulled it from just a couple threads down.  Here

  • I always had my own room growing up and I would've hated to share with my sister. I'm a super neat freak and she is the biggest slob ever. So, I would really like for my kids to have their own room when they are older. However, I don't think they NEED it. If we could only afford a 2 bedroom forever I wouldn't settle on just having 1 kid b/c I have always wanted more than 1.
  • Like I said in the post below My younger sister and I shared a room for 5 years before we moved into a bigger house.  My older sister got her own room, eventually we all had our own rooms which was nice.

    We plan on having them share for alittle while, as we (Dh and I) feel it is important since it teaches things like tolerance and patience with another person, however we both feel that different Genders should not be in the same room after a certain age, simply for privacy reasons, and once they are teenagers they will be in their own rooms to give them the soace and privacy that they will need.

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker BabyFruit Ticker image


    image
  • They dont need it but if you can afford it i would definitely consider upgrading to a bigger house.  I think it's nice to be able to give each child their own unique space.  If you can't afford it, not biggie either.
  • Of course not.  Humans raised children in huts for a million years, and still do in some places.
    image

    Big sister {September 2008} Sweet boy {April 2011} Fuzzy Bundle {ETA July 2014}

    Pregnancy Ticker
  • They don't need their own room. But my H had to share a room with his brother his whole life and he said it got pretty old, especially once they hit the teenage years and had no privacy at all.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    DD #1 passed away in January 2011 at 14 days old due to congenital heart disease
    DD#2 lost in January 2012 at 23 weeks due to anhydramnios caused by a placental abruption
  • imageDonniesgrrl:

    We plan on having them share for alittle while, as we (Dh and I) feel it is important since it teaches things like tolerance and patience with another person, however we both feel that different Genders should not be in the same room after a certain age, simply for privacy reasons, and once they are teenagers they will be in their own rooms to give them the soace and privacy that they will need.

    Interesting plan.  I think I may steal it.

     

  • need, no, but its a nice perk.

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
  • I think its fine for siblings of the same sex to share. Like the Brady Bunch ;) I shared a room with my sister many times throughout our life, even when there was an open room. We liked it. But we also liked each other. We were both kind of lonely in our own rooms, and she would often come sleep in my room just because it was more fun. lol We are still best friends.

    If we have another room, I would probably keep the boys in a room together if they get along well. If they want their own rooms, I would give it to them, but I think its good to learn how to share space, and I think you bond well this way. However, I would keep the extra room as a play room or game room.

    I wouldn't upgrade my house solely based on the amount of rooms, but we live in a house right now that would accomodate another kid, and hopefully we wouldn't have to "downgrade."

  • No way do they need their own rooms! It's nice, but certainly not a necessity! I think it can be good for kids to have the experience of sharing at some point. I shared w/ my brother (twin beds) until I was about 7, when my baby bro was big enough to move out of the crib, and then the boys shared nad I had my own room. I loved sharing. We had lots of fun. Then, I also loved having my own room later.
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Fifth Birthday tickers Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • Okay, I obviously can't type - I meant if we have another boy, not room.

    And I just read that other post - I think its more difficult when dealing with step kids. I would talk with the older kids and see how they feel about it. You don't want to give them the shaft, and make them feel like they aren't important, which is how they might feel if you shove a kid in their room. Step kids make things a little trickier. I would talk to the older kids first.

    However, I wouldn't be opposed to have 2 younger kids - say, under the age of 3 or 4 in the same room. But I don't know, they might want their privacy. That's a tough one.

  • i had my own room, i guess, until my sister was born when i was 5. thus, i have no memories of having my own room. Crying i really don't think it's necessary. we definitely didn't get along sometimes, but it was still good to share a room.

    that being said, yes, i would upgrade my house solely for this purpose, if we could afford it.

  • My sister had a 4 bedroom house and my nephews still shared a room. They used the "BIG" room as the play room since they had a smaller family room and no basement. The 4th bedroom was the guest room. They liked sharing rooms.

    I def. don't think it's a necessity; however, if I had a boy and a girl I'd prefer they have there own rooms. I shared a room with my brother for a year or two growing up and I hated it.

    Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers
  • I don't think it's a need, except in the case of different genders.  We only have two other bedrooms in our house and probably aren't moving anytime real soon (we love our house!) so if we have three children some will be sharing a room.  No biggie.  The living room and kitchen areas are larger, and we can all hang out there.    
  • Nope. We have a 3br house and our girls share a room because my oldest wants the baby with her. Doesn't matter to me either way. If they want their own rooms they can have them, if not that is fine too.

    We are moving to a bigger house and the girls WILL have their own bathroom, but that is more for me than them -- I don't want them poking around in my grown-up stuff, hehe.

  • Yes IMO all kids need their own space. We will not have #3 until we can afford a bigger house.

  • Growing up my sister and I had our own rooms, but we'd go back and forth between sharing and being separate. A friend of mine shared a tiny bedroom with two sisters. It's definitely not necessary! I think there are definite advantages to sharing rooms: closeness with sibs, learning to respect the property of others, patience, etc. But there are advantages to being separate too.
    S- March 09 E- Feb 12 L- May 15


  • I think children can share rooms with each other and it is actually a good thing - teaches them how to get along with another person. Yes, they'll argue over who made what mess, but it's a good learning process.

    My brother and sister were twins and shared a room for years, until mom and dad managed to convince them that they needed to split. After that, my sis and I shared. It was difficult going from having my own room to sharing, but it helped me and I was closer to my sister because of it.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • of course not. my family of 6 lived in a 3 bedroom 1 bathroom house from the time i was 8. it was fine. i never once felt deprived or like i needed my own space. sharing and living together was expected in my family. even as a teenager i didn't care at all that i was sharing a room with my sister...never even occurred to me. i think it's pretty silly and a wee bit spoiled to believe that you HAVE to have a separate room for each child. sure it's nice, but necessary? not at all. and their own BATHroom? i didn't even know people thought this was necessary.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"