- Pregnancy
- Baby & Toddler
- Parents
- Getting Pregnant
- Baby Names
- Product Reviews
-
Registry
- Community
-
More
Want a personalized experience?
Download the free app
Cincinnati Babies
Still can't decide on a girls name. Help.
I've tried creating a poll but for some reason it won't work for me. We still have not finalized a girls name yet. Why are girls name so much harder? UGH.
Here are the finalists.
Sadie Evelyn
Sadie Harper
Harper Rose
Harper Evelyn
Brooke Harper
Brooke Evelyn
We originally took Sadie out of the mix but then we just kept coming back to it because we really do like it a lot even though people said it is a dog's name. I just keep thinking we had a dog named Missy growing up and I don't think my friend Missy has a dog's name. Ya know.
We really love Harper too because it is different but not sure about it with our last name since it is longer and little harder to pronounce. However it is so pretty.
Brooke is pretty too and goes well with our last name but not sure if it is too common of a name. We do really like names that not as popular and common but not too out there like celebrity baby names either like Apple or Shiloh, etc.
I think we are having a hard time because we loved Mya so much that we are trying to find something that we love just as much and goes well with her name too.
Am I completely nuts for thinking so much about this?
This discussion has been closed.
Re: Still can't decide on a girls name. Help.
I obsessed over names too!
Since both are in your list, I should mention that a name I loved for a girl was Evelyn Rose. Sorry that wasn't helpful was it. 
Brooke is too common for me. I don't really know about Sadie, but I didn't think dog at all, but NMS. Harper is cute! I don't know that I love the MNs you picked with it, but I don't know your last name and that could make or break them for me.
Of your list, the one I like the best is Harper Rose.
Elijah Matthew - 5/3/07 ~ Adalyn Rosemary - 3/23/11
*Photos by Kacy Cierley*
Mason Louise
I vote for Harper Rose. I love Harper.
However, I agree that you must be coming back to Sadie for a reason. I would not rule it out on the pet-name thing. Our dog's name is Lindsey but I never meet people named Lindsey and think of my dog the whole time, you know?
So I will also throw in a vote for Sadie Evelyn. I also love Sadie Rose, but I know that's not a choice
. Sadie is classic, cute and yet ageless, and simple.
My thoughts exactly!
Like I said in your previous name post, I love Harper and Sadie! Harper Rose is really pretty.
I think of all the choices, Sadie Evelyn and Brooke Evelyn would be my top choices. I do know your last name and I don't think I'd use Harper for a first name for sure with it, but I don't even think I'd use Harper as a MN with that last name (too much of the -ER sound).
I think Sadie would be a darling name and goes really nicely with Mya, as does Brooke. I just think Sadie edges out Brooke for me but I love them both.
Tyler Anthony arrived on 9.21.09
The Chronicles of Justin and Tyler
I vote for Harper Rose or Sadie Evelyn. I like Harper better but obvioulsy you are going back to Sadie for a reason.
I know how you feel. DH and I just finalized a girl name last night, I thought we never would.
I have to agree that girls names are much harder! We are Team Green and had a boys name pretty quickly... and are still struggling with a girls name (which probably means it's a girl
)
My vote is for Sadie. I think it is very pretty, goes well with Mya, and it seems like you guys like it the best since you keep going back to it.
FWIW, I like Harper, but have heard it a lot lately. I feel like it's going to be a very popular, trendy name.
Brooke would be my runner up.
GL! I know it's hard!
LOVE Brooke!!!!!!
This is late but I love Brooke Evelyn. ?I don't know anyone with a child named Brooke so I don't really think it's very common at all. ?
Michelle?
Brooke Evelyn is still my favorite. I think it flows really well with your last name. I do like Brooke Harper too.
Brooke & Mya = very cute