please tell me that someone agrees with me (American Idol)

mrscrowell5308 · March 2009

and that im not the meanest person. but scott needs to go home. its amazing what he can do but i just dont enjoy his singing and its kinda awkward to watch. he's really nice but i jsut dont think that he's that good. he could be a great writer but not sure if this is the career for him.

mikkimikey · March 2009

I agree completely! I think that he makes it through due to his disability, which is a shame. Probably not for him, but it's just sort of strange to watch sometimes because there are people who are much better than him going home. JMO!

MrsMSG · March 2009

Amen, and amen. I've felt this way for a while.

nicole7579 · March 2009

I couldn't agree more!!!

SaraBobby · March 2009

I didn't like him since the begining... but last week I enjoyed watching him. I am ready to see Megan Joy go!

AlpacaBunny · March 2009

I think he is a great singer/composer but I don't think he's the next american idol. I think he will have a great career ahead of him, but I don't think his style is going to appeal to the masses of teenagers who are watching. Another thing is that I think that Megan girl needs to go...her voice irritates the crap out of me.

LLarson · March 2009

yes i agree!!! im all for kris allen though

liongish119 · March 2009

He's a mediocre singer at best, although I do think he plays the piano well. I think he or Megan should be the next to be kicked off.

pollykinz · April 2009

Right there with ya girls! I have thought he was mediocre from the beginning and couldn't believe he made it through to the top. I did think he was better last night than he's been, but he still needs to be one of the next to go. If Megan "Twitch" Joy doesn't go home tonight, I will be PISSED!!! She is God awful and last night was just painful!! LOL

please tell me that someone agrees with me (American Idol)

Re: please tell me that someone agrees with me (American Idol)

Choose Another Board

Search Boards