I received a catalog from https://www.1stwishes.com/ in the mail yesterday, and they really have some cute stuff! This part of the site focuses on first birthdays, but if you click on the link for "Birthday Express" at the top of the page you'll find stuff for ALL birthdays.
I had it pretty easy - the ladybugs theme was featured on the back of the catalog and DH immediately said "We're using that, right?"
Re: PSA: Awesome birthday party supply site!
Ooooh, I have seen this stuff! My friend used some of their rubber ducky stuff. The duck party favor is one of DDs favorite toys, LOL.
I like the Hugs and Stitches.
EDIT: OMG- the ladybugs are adorable!! If I wasnt doing butterflies I might have to steal those!
I ordered Gavin the cowboy birthday stuff from them and I rec'd it yesterday. It's pretty darn cute!!!