Paige or Peyton?

whatididntkno

We have our boy name picked out, but DH and I have had a really hard time agreeing on girl names. It seems to be down to these two contenders, but we can't decide which we like better:

Paige Marisol

Peyton Marisol

demelzacat

I prefer Paige.

BootsyLou

Paige.

Ewych82

Definitely Paige.

Mochadoodle

Paige

JemmaWRX

Definitely Paige.  Peyton is terrible for a boy or a girl, but especially awful for a girl.  Marisol is nice!

Fletch82

Another vote for Paige

bsinno

I also like the name paige better!

dreemkin84

I like the name Paige but not with marisol. Peyton reminds me of the movie the hand that rocks the cradle 

firsttimeauntie

Paige

capulet

Paige.  Peyton doesn't sound like a girl name to me

LtlAngL

Paige. Peyton is a football player, not a little girl.

whatididntkno

Thank you guys for your comments! Several of them made me laugh Peyton was DH's suggestion. I didn't like it at first but it grew on me.

Paige for the win!

chapstix7

Overwhelmingly Paige!

nebraska84

Paige

rbtrumpet

Peyton is kind of a GP name of mine, but in reality I would pick Paige.

LISHAKAE

I really like Peyton

whoopsybaby

NMS, but I prefer Paige a thousand times over Peyton

hollyk224

I love Paige!

g8trkim

Paige x1,000

WashingtonQueen

Paige by a long shot!!

blaa27

Paige Marisol

Peyton Marisol

 

I'm not a fan on Paige to begin with because I think its dated and its time has passed.

And paired with Marisol and pitted against Peyton, I say Peyton.

Hands down, no contest for me.

Peyton paired with Marisol is rather refreshing to me, perfectly feminine. 

crwel1048

I use to love the name Peyton, but I'm kind of over it! I'm going with Paige on this one. And I'm a big fan of Marisol!

rockopera

Paige.

salt78

I think Paige Marisol is GORGEOUS. I can't stand Peyton for a little girl. It just makes me think of Peyton Manning and I really don't like him.

Pepper6

Paige for sure.  Peyton is way too trendy and it's a boys name.

brookelynpaisley

Paige.

Peyton is masculine.