We have the Diaper Genie (II) and we love it. But, we never had anything else, so I have nothing to compare it to. Some people say it stinks, but I think it just depends on how often you empty it and how stinky your kid was that day. &
We have the Arm Hammer, and it's great. For the first year, we just had a small garbage can that needed to be emptied every day or two, and we put poop diapers in a dog poo bag before they went into the garbage can. It worked fine for that amount of time
Finally updating my signature and avatar, August 29, 2011 (better late than never!)
Jake! (born July 3, 2011 - 6 days past due)
December Siggy Challenge: Favorite Holiday Movie
Re: Diaper pail?
I hated using the diaper can things.
I ended up just tossing the diaper in a plastic grocery bag, tying it up and throwing it away outside.