Let's take the gov out of marriage completely.
So, anyone married by a judge, sea captain, Elvis, etc, sorry but now you are no longer married. Only those who are married by the religious figure of their choice get to stay married.
But let's not stop there. Forget the fact if you are "married" or not now, no more governmental benefits to being married anyway!! Let's stop health insurance benefits, tax deductions, pension sharing. Nope. Sorry. The government no longer recognizes marriage so there is no longer benefits associated with that.
I wonder what the religious would say about that? Not fair! Maybe. But if they do, then we could say, why not? You're still married in the eyes of your god, just not in the eyes of the government. And since you don't think everyone should receive those governmental benefits, really, why should anyone? Maybe then they'd change their tune.
Sorry for the vent. I was getting worked up about something on FB and I felt like this was a safe place to let off some steam.
Re: Since religious folks don't want the gov to redefine "marriage"...
Me either. It defies all logical sense.
That said, I don't think your argument would work. The ones that are really opposed would welcome the idea. The gays being blocked from marriage trumps everything. Even money. Most people like this are also semi well off so they'd just say they would plan financially to provide for one another, and that we should all do that.
Or they'd argue that if they hit hard times, other Christians will bail them out.
It is the "neener neener boo boo" argument. We have it. We don't want others to have it. Therefore we are superior.
Marriage has be redefined countless times in the existence of man. The whole "don't redefine my marriage, bro" is akin to ignorance of the argument "Keep your government out of my medicare".
Preach
.
I would say the same for any religion as well.
Because if you give them the choice to discriminate against same-sex couples, then some will.
I don't either. Both as a Christian and as a decent human bean, this sh!t makes me sick. I don't remember hearing god say that judging others and denying them their rights made us right in his eyes.
Please don't put me on a post it for being Christian. I am pro choice, pro birth control, and pro gay marriage.
Damn it. I swear I typed being. I need non mobile bump or more coffee.
Sorry. I wasn't trying to say "all" but it seems like the majority of people opposed to allowing gays to marry are religious. But yes, my parents are both religious, but they also believe strongly in equal civil rights.
And I know my idea wouldn't "work" but that's the point. Maybe then people would see that legal marriage is about more than their religious beliefs.
Now I am going to bump and run. Thank you ladies and gent for allowing me this vent!
Lol it is okay. I thought it was funny.
I am sorry, I didn't word that well. Many of the vocal people I know who oppose gay marriage are well off and would be fine with losing money to ban gay marriage.
I have tried the 24 hour marriage argument and the adultery still ejnf legal and was told it was free will to sin or sumsh!t. I asked why it wasn't okay for gays to have free will as well and didnt get an answer.
I don't care who marries either. I just want everyone to have te right to be married.
I know you didn't mean that every religious person was like that, but I feel the constant need to point out we aren't all dicks, since it seems like the vocal ones are.
I wish people were less stubborn about this. I don't know how to argue anymore. I don't think they get AT ALL the financial benefits of marriage, and if they do, many are so stubborn they'd be okay with losing them.
My dad is gay and raised me. I turned out okay. And I didn't catch the "gay gene" or whatever other nonsense they spew.
You do, however, try to get bacon kisses from women who are not your wife. Tsk, tsk.
It makes me sick that people say that stuff.
I'm a hot mess when it comes to this issue. I contradict myself and look like a hypocrite and can't very well articulate how I actually feel about it. So, if this makes zero sense to you I understand.
Let me also preface this with: I am a Christian. I believe homosexuality is a sin. I also believe that homosexuals are loved by God regardless of their sin, as are all sinners, and can go to heaven. God doesn't have "levels" of sins... the inmate on death row has committed no worse sins in God's eyes than I did by telling a white lie. So, as long as I continue to sin (so as long as I live because nobody is perfect), I commit no worse offense in God's eyes than a homosexual. I believe that I serve a loving, forgiving God who in no way would want me to spew hatred or discriminate against anyone, for any reason.
In my pre-bump days, in my sheltered Christian life in Podunk, I was 100% against gay marriage. Who are they to steal the sanctity of my union?! The mere thought appalled me. Then I talked to my Papaw, a Baptist minister, who explained the "God has no "levels" of sins" thing to me, and told me that I most certainly would see people in heaven who were homosexuals on earth. (we believe that there is no sexuality/unions in heaven) So wait, what? My Papaw, the most conservative man I know, says that gay people aren't "evil", and that letting them be married in no way effects my marriage?
Enter the bump into my life. I'm exposed to so many different cultures and lifestyles and life choices... I learn that I can respectfully disagree with others, we don't have to share the same views... and someone says to me, "Why is it any of the government's business who gets married? Why does YOUR church/religion have the final say? Would you love your husband any less, or be any less committed to him should a gay couple be given their right to be married? Why can't gay people be legally married, but just not recognized in the eyes of the church? Why does the church get to dictate what is legal?" BOOM. I get it now.
I'm still not a fan of gay marriage, but only because I don't support homosexuality. My God tells me to "Love thy neighbor as they self", and that's what I plan to do. Love everyone, regardless of their sexual orientation, religion, or color. Let every human have the same rights, let them be married if they wish. I'm still going to honor my vows and love my husband with every fiber of my being, regardless of if another man loves his husband this much too.
Sorry if this makes no sense to anyone else. I'm still trying to find a short, simple way to say it. Maybe: God tells us to love one another. No exceptions. Let them be married.
And, I should add this:
212 Facebook Admin.
So, your argument is that we should allow systematic discrimination because those facing discrimination will gravitate toward companies that don't discriminate?
It seems like an undue burden on a gay family. Why should they face limited employment and health insurance just because they're gay? Would you say the same if insurance companies didn't want to insure spouses of differing races?
Not to mention that the economic climate isn't exactly prime for picking and choosing jobs, many are happy just to have employment - let alone be in the position to turn down another job.
And even if a gay man or woman is in a position to turn down a job because of its insurance policy in favor of the exact same job at a company that insures same-sex couples, there's a surplus of employees and gay people only make up something like 5% of the population, so companies aren't likely to face a whole lot of pressure to change.
lol
I am so happy I don't know any one who believes this IRL. Also WTF is a Papaw? Is this for real?
So if you believe in God and believe he doesn't make mistakes, then it would be safe to say he made people gay for a reason. Maybe that reason was to point out all of the hypocrites. Maybe it's because he doesn't view homosexuality as abnormal at all.
For the record, I believe in science and God. So maybe I am giving too much credit to people to do their research.
A Papaw is a grandfather. It's just what we call them around here.
And you're glad that you don't know anyone IRL who believes that we should love and accept and grant equal rights to all humans regardless of if we agree with their lifestyle or not?
212 Facebook Admin.
I am embarrassed but love this graphic so am also glad I made this mistake.
I want to invite some of these haters to meet my daughter,
her partner, and their 14mo old son. Spend some time
with them. And then tell us to our faces that they shouldn't
have all the rights of hetero's.
I would start with mommyliberty, and catsarenice from
The Nest PC&E board.
Because the bible says it is wrong. Now, if you read from a historical context and if you read and understand the whole chapter and bible, not just select verses, you walk away with a different picture. Which is why many sects of Christianity are now accepting and performing gay marriages.
My father and his partner both attend a Methodist church in Texas.
It blows minds there.
You know what I don't get?
Why American's fight so damn much about EVERYTHING!! Gay marriage, abortion, and all the other things you guys argue so much about are such non issues in Canada (and in most other developed countries). Don't you get sick of it all? I sure do, and I only see it on TB and on American news. I would go crazy if I had to see this crap on FB and IRL too.
It's because we have the highest Defense Budget in the world. We like to fight and blow shiit up.
Thank you, it was humbling to realize that I was so incredibly wrong.
I don't feel like I'm judging homosexuals, or begrudgingly giving them equal rights. I disagree with their lifestyle, but I don't judge them for it.
212 Facebook Admin.
Can you explain why? I simply honest to God cannot understand.
Probably not in a way that would make any logical sense to anyone here. I suck at explaining my beliefs (because I don't want to offend anyone), and I'm still trying to learn and research and make more informed decisions on the subject. Where I'm at right now, I disagree with the lifestyle because it goes against everything I've been taught since I was in the womb. I'm just scratching the surface of "step outside of your comfort zone and learn for yourself".
I don't pretend to be the final authority on God's word, or God's will. I'm just trying to live by the Bible in the way I interpret it.
212 Facebook Admin.
You all say it so much better than I did. What made me first reexamine all this and seek out someone who could talk to me about the historical context and all that and explain why he preached homosexuality wasn't a sin was when I realized the Old Testament would have had me marry my rapist. I knew no kind God would do that, so I wondered if I understood it wrong.
I feel like many people miss out by taking it word for word and not looking at who said what, when they said it, what words they used, and so on.
I just don't see where diagreeing with someone's lifestyle = judging that lifestyle.
My bottom line is that I want my fellow Christians to love people unconditionally. I don't care if you're gay or straight, you're still human, you deserve to be loved, and you deserve the exact same rights as anyone else.
212 Facebook Admin.
Because I'm still learning the snarky ways, I will just use a quote to best explain how I feel about this subject:
?For nearly a century, the moral relativism of science has given faith-based religion--that great engine of ignorance and bigotry--a nearly uncontested claim to being the only universal framework for moral wisdom. As a result, the most powerful societies on early spend their time debating issues like gay marriage when they should be focused on problems like nuclear proliferation, genocide, energy security, climate change, poverty, and failing schools.?
-Sam Harris
Ditto to what Spooko said.
I commend you for how far you've come. And I (gently) remind you that there are many things that people have been taught since the womb that are not entirely accurate. Its really hard to rewrite one's beliefs, but its often worth it.
I can't really help you with the religious research, but I can certainly help you in other areas. For instance, I think gayness is as natural as nature and I encourage you to read up on my favorite primate: the bonobo. Or just animals in general.