Two Questions...

Sawyerplus1

1. If you already had a DD named Olivia, but who went by Livi 99% of the time, would you name a DS Oscar?  Oscar and Olivia, though starting with the same letter, arent too similar are they? 

2. If you think Oscar would be fine to use, do you think Oscar James sounds nice?

TIA!  

trojas

1. Yes.

2. Not entirely crazy about Oscar James.  

Sawyerplus1

trojas:

1. Yes.

2. Not entirely crazy about Oscar James.  

Any suggestions? DH and I are tossing around the name Oscar, but having a really hard time with middle names.  

WiFeY 4 LiFeY

1. not a big deal, they dont sound close at all

2. cute!

kmpls

Not a big deal. I don't like the initials OJ, or Oscar really.

MLSF

Not a fan of Oscar. I think of Oscar the grouch.   James Oscar is better IMO

ahappyrobot

mj.reilly:

1. Sure, apart from both starting with O, they sound completely different.

2. LOVE!

This. Oscar is really great.

fish000

Fine as a sibset. Even has a nice ring to it IMO.

Oscar James is lovely.

karen_loy

kmpls:

Not a big deal. I don't like the initials OJ, or Oscar really.

same here

CiderWench

1. Yes. Aside from the O, they are very different names.

2. I think Oscar James both sounds and looks nice, although I do find James to be kind of a filler middle name for boys. I love Oscar!

Sawyerplus1

CiderWench:

2. I think Oscar James both sounds and looks nice, although I do find James to be kind of a filler middle name for boys. 

True, but it's also my dad name  

g8trkim

They may both start with an O but they don't have the same sound at all, so I don't think it's a big deal. If you plan on having more kids and naming them all O names, that could be weird but I wouldn't think anything of two kids with the same letter.

Oscar James is a nice name so go for it.

Sawyerplus1

g8trkim:

They may both start with an O but they don't have the same sound at all, so I don't think it's a big deal. If you plan on having more kids and naming them all O names, that could be weird but I wouldn't think anything of two kids with the same letter.

Oscar James is a nice name so go for it.

We also have a DS named Sawyer, so it's too late for an 'O' theme (thank goodness)

FrecklesInside

karen_loy:

kmpls:

Not a big deal. I don't like the initials OJ, or Oscar really.

same here

This for me too.

Oscar James sounds nice though...

Some other suggestions:

Oscar Matthew

Oscar Thomas

Oscar Isacc

Oscar Hugo

Oscar Adam

Oscar Joseph

salt78

I do not think they are too similar at all (actually I think they are a very cute sibset). 

And Oscar James is a great name!