Is this sibling set too "matchy"?

DevonPow

We are now thinking Charles Lawrence for DS2. However, we would call him Charlie and I am worried that Charlie and Henry is too matchy/rhyme-y.....what do you think?

Our other current thoughts are Elliott Lawrence (I really don't like that it is being used as a girls name, plus a cousin due a month before us may use it, so it may be out), Maxwell Lawrence (concerned about popularity), Calvin Lawrence (I am just not sold), and Gabriel Lawrence (nothing wrong with it, but it doesn't grab me)

CaitlinJ22

no I think its perfect

JMU_Bride09

I don't think they're too matchy.

emikat

Not too matchy. 

AshleyC0117

I love Charles and Henry! I think it's a great sibset even if you call him Charlie. I also love Elliott... it was one of my top 2 names if I was having a boy. You have great name taste!

perfectpair1275

I think they sound great together, definitely not too matchy!

Loganswife

I really like Charles (Charlie) and Henry together.

Candace52309

Far from matchy... Sounds great together!

 

alohamora

I don't think they're too matchy at all.  I love Charles Lawrence.

Jazzyashes84

Maxwell Lawrence...I like this best. But charlie/henry aren't too matchy

Schnebs

I don't think they are too matchy.

erinms

I love Charlie and Henry together, great choice!

JANEhickey

DevonPow:

We are now thinking Charles Lawrence for DS2. However, we would call him Charlie and I am worried that Charlie and Henry is too matchy/rhyme-y.....what do you think?

Our other current thoughts are Elliott Lawrence (I really don't like that it is being used as a girls name, plus a cousin due a month before us may use it, so it may be out), Maxwell Lawrence (concerned about popularity), Calvin Lawrence (I am just not sold), and Gabriel Lawrence (nothing wrong with it, but it doesn't grab me)

LOVE Calvin. I prefer Eli or Elias to Elliott. 

queenbone

Nope, Charles and Henry are great. 

I don't count the diminutives when I consider matchy-ness.  Otherwise, practically everything would be matchy.

jenjury

they sounds great! Classic names are fantastic.

I have a Charlie and it's a GREAT name. 

mrebecca

DevonPow:

We are now thinking Charles Lawrence for DS2. However, we would call him Charlie and I am worried that Charlie and Henry is too matchy/rhyme-y.....what do you think?

Our other current thoughts are Elliott Lawrence (I really don't like that it is being used as a girls name, plus a cousin due a month before us may use it, so it may be out), Maxwell Lawrence (concerned about popularity), Calvin Lawrence (I am just not sold), and Gabriel Lawrence (nothing wrong with it, but it doesn't grab me)

Looks like you went with Elliot. He's handsome! 

melody921

I think it sounds great together.

brookelynpaisley

Who the hell is digging up all these old threads?