Ugh. Can't decide! Too close?

erbear

DH and I had a girl name down to Caroline and Emily. We've been talking about those two for months. Today he throws out Claire. I can't decide if I like it or not...or if it's too close to dd's name (Kate). Opinions?

KoalaBear103

LOVE all the names!!  I don't think Claire is too close to Kate, but I think I like Caroline and Emily better.

FemmeNat01

I love Caroline. Claire it cute too. I don't think it's too similiar.

crystal959

I love all three names, but I like Caroline the most.

queenbone

I'd pick Emily over Caroline or Claire. They both have the same beginning sound as Kate, which is too close for me.

LMS05

I don't think it's too close. Claire is my favorite, but I also love Caroline. Emily is nice, but I like the other two much more. 

Soon2BMrsN

I love Claire and Caroline, but not Emily.  I mean, it's a fine name, but not really "special" to me.

12bailey18

I think having siblings named Kate and Claire is very cute!! I love the name Claire- classic, pretty, and it ages well. Great choices!

kizz11

not too close.  i love claire!

supermanda

Claire!!! Loving that name right now! Emily is a good solid name but I like Claire better, Caroline is NMS.

MommyNoelle

I guess I'm the odd man out, but I think Kate and Claire are too close.

elisbu

I love Kate and Claire!

I love Kate and Caroline.

I don't love Emily. It's VERY popular right now, and I think your LO would end up going by Emily LN, because of it.

ErinLee30

My vote is Claire! Love that name.

NicoleWI

Claire is OK but I like Caroline and Emily better. Funny, we have a Katie and are considering Caroline and Emily (plus Carolina but likely not using that b/c of our last name). Love both names.

SubtleGrandeur

I love all three names!  My name is Kate (Katherine), so I'm kind of partial to it. However, I must admit that I'd probably pick Emily. You really can't go wrong, though.