If it's going to be used to snuggle with, the 11-inch (when the 18-inch is "folded" it is HUGE for my 6-year-old to snuggle in her sleep). If it's going to be used as an actual pillow, then definitely the 18-inch. DD has an 18-inch one (penguin) and loves it... she does snuggle with it sometimes, but 95% of the time she sleeps on it.
Mom to J (10), L (4), and baby #3 arriving in July of 2015
The big one. My 3YO has the big one and sleeps on it (I don't know how that's comfortable but she just throws regular pillows off the bed). I just bought a little one as a gift for a baby friend turning 1 - she's teeny and will use it more as a stuffed animal.
Re: What size Pillow Pet to get?
{Ava 5.16.06} {Ella 12.29.07} {Drew 2.9.10}