Indy Cake/Bakery recs?

jettagurl

Anyone you can suggest?  We've been thru a few...and just found a great one on the southside who is now moving to Chicago - ugh! 

We've primarily used solo ladies, not shops.....we want someone with mad decorating skills....with frosting, not fondant.

I prefer E/ NE / SE, but I'll check out anyone.  

Thanks!

 

katelynsmom

I've gotten many cakes through Taylors Bakery. They have 2 locations. 116th in Fishers and around 56th/Allisonville.

Their cakes taste very good. I think if you go to their website, they have a bunch of cakes you can look at. 

SusieDMB

My favorite cakes for that sort of thing are from pat-a-cakes and cookies too--they just opened a 2nd shop at 116th & Olio by the bw3's (original is in Noblesville). 

I also hear good things about a slice of heaven cakery which now has a shop in Lapel.

 I may be the oddball, but I'm not a fan of taylor's cakes.  

mbs427

Love, love, love Classic Cakes in Carmel 

caitlet425

mbs427:

Love, love, love Classic Cakes in Carmel 

I completely agree on this rec too! We luuuuuuuurve them! But, I also like Taylor's bakery as well (116th st in Fisher's).

gizmo909

mbs427:

Love, love, love Classic Cakes in Carmel 

This.  Mmmmmmm!