Bonavita Hudson or Peyton Collection?

B-lineBride

Just curious if anyone has the crib or dresser from either of these collections. Looking for a little insight into the quality once they've been put to use. We're debating between one of these or a set from Pottery Barn, which has mixed reveiws for long-term durability. Thanks!

schnappycat

I have a Hudson Lifestyle crib on order, but it's not here yet, so I can't vouch for it. But it's generally gotten great reviews, where I have seen mixed things about PB, too. 

ruby930

We were actually looking at the Peyton combo dresser and 5-drawer dresser, but decided on something else because the color selections didn't match the color of the crib that was purchased for us (LONG story...).

If the colors would have matched, I totally would have gone with the Peyton collection.  It is classic, well-made, reasonably priced and gets good reviews. 

08summerbride

My neighbor just had the hudson collection set up in their nursery and they like it a lot.  The baby isn't due until april, so it hasn't actually been used yet, but they are happy with the quaility of construction.  Their nursery looks very nice with the crib, double dresser and hutch.

JenniferL923

We've got the Peyton collection and its soooo nice.  I have pics in my blog.  I keep telling DH its got to be the nicest furniture we have in the house.  Plus Baby Bargains gives Bonavita great marks, whereas they don't seem too thrilled with the PBK stuff.  We were thinking about a PBK collection until we went to compare the two and read more reviews.

brits4

I have the Peyton collection and I LOVE it! It is over a year old and it looks amazing!  I plan on using this set for my DS for years to come.  We bought the conversion set for the crib.