3rd Trimester

Has anyone heard of..

I know this is probably really gross lol, but has anyone ever had a grilled peanut butter and jelly sandwich?

Someone just told me it was the best thing they've ever eaten.. I've never had it, but apparently you make a normal pbnj, put butter on the outside of the bread, and grill it like a  grilled cheese. I've never heard of this before now.

ETA: Apparently it doesn't sound gross at all =) It's just different and I'm thinking I'm gonna try it. lol

Re: Has anyone heard of..

  • Not gross....heavenly!!! I put the jelly on afterwards so it doesn't get runny and hot.  It's hot & cold like a fudge sundae. Hmmm..... ::glances around kitchen:: I'll be right back. LOL
    Lilypie Second Birthday tickers Lilypie Maternity tickers ***This space reserved for photo of new squish***
  • Hey there! how are you? I've heard of a fried banana & peanut butter sandwich which are totally awesome but never one with Jelly. Are you going to try it? if so let me know how it turns out
  • Loading the player...
  • That actually sounds pretty good to me. BUT I'm also the kinda girl who realllllly loves her fried PB&Js on the boardwalk down the shore ;)
  • imageStrawberryAlarmClock:
    Not gross....heavenly!!! I put the jelly on afterwards so it doesn't get runny and hot.  It's hot & cold like a fudge sundae. Hmmm..... ::glances around kitchen:: I'll be right back. LOL

    Really?! I'm obsessed with pbnj and I'm really considering trying this. How do I do it? Put the peanut butter on, butter the outsides like a grilled cheese? And then what?

  • I've never had it, but is sounds good.  I eat peanut butter toast and it doesn't sound too different than that....
  • imageParadisemoon:
    Hey there! how are you? I've heard of a fried banana & peanut butter sandwich which are totally awesome but never one with Jelly. Are you going to try it? if so let me know how it turns out

    I'm good! How are you? I'm definitely gonna try it.. I think.. lol I'll let you know.

  • imageDreamsBride411:
    That actually sounds pretty good to me. BUT I'm also the kinda girl who realllllly loves her fried PB&Js on the boardwalk down the shore ;)

    Lol I love that you call it "down the shore." =) Makes me giggle. All of my out of town friends call the boardwalk/beach "the shore".  

  • Ohh I eat those sometimes! I always thought they might be just a southern thing. I dont know.. Anyways, the way I make it is just like a regular PB and J, butter the outsides of the bread then grill it like a grilled cheese. Some people put jelly on afterwards but once the peanut butter gets hot and melts it burns if it gets on you so be careful. lol. Yeah. Enjoy!
  • imageAmyLovesEddie14:

    imageStrawberryAlarmClock:
    Not gross....heavenly!!! I put the jelly on afterwards so it doesn't get runny and hot.  It's hot & cold like a fudge sundae. Hmmm..... ::glances around kitchen:: I'll be right back. LOL

    Really?! I'm obsessed with pbnj and I'm really considering trying this. How do I do it? Put the peanut butter on, butter the outsides like a grilled cheese? And then what?

    Butter one side, PB the other and brown them in the skillet.  Slap on the jelly and voila!

    Lilypie Second Birthday tickers Lilypie Maternity tickers ***This space reserved for photo of new squish***
  • This sounds so good right now!
  • imageStrawberryAlarmClock:
    imageAmyLovesEddie14:

    imageStrawberryAlarmClock:
    Not gross....heavenly!!! I put the jelly on afterwards so it doesn't get runny and hot.  It's hot & cold like a fudge sundae. Hmmm..... ::glances around kitchen:: I'll be right back. LOL

    Really?! I'm obsessed with pbnj and I'm really considering trying this. How do I do it? Put the peanut butter on, butter the outsides like a grilled cheese? And then what?

    Butter one side, PB the other and brown them in the skillet.  Slap on the jelly and voila!

    Thanks! I just ate a bus load of food, but when I'm hungry again, in an hour.. lol, this is what I'm eating. =)

  • MMMM sounds delish!
  • I'll do you one better...

    French toast PB & J.  I nearly died when I had this.  Saw it on the Food Network.

    You dip one side of the bread in french toast mix (eggs, milk & cinnamon), put that in the pan, spread jelly (I like blueberry) on the plain side.  Peanut butter one side of the other bread.  Dip the plain side in the french toast mix and put it on top of the other half to complete the sandwich.  Fry both sides until done.  I didn't add syrup, but I suppose you could if you wanted to.  

    This is ridiculously yummy! :oP 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageCheriLooWho:

    I'll do you one better...

    French toast PB & J.  I nearly died when I had this.  Saw it on the Food Network.

    You dip one side of the bread in french toast mix (eggs, milk & cinnamon), put that in the pan, spread jelly (I like blueberry) on the plain side.  Peanut butter one side of the other bread.  Dip the plain side in the french toast mix and put it on top of the other half to complete the sandwich.  Fry both sides until done.  I didn't add syrup, but I suppose you could if you wanted to.  

    This is ridiculously yummy! :oP 

    mmmm If my heartburn wasn't killing me right now, I'd be tearing apart my kitchen for some type of grilled pbnj or pbnj/french toast. lol

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"