Ok I need birthday party food help

jamie4duke

Kelsey's party is on Sunday.  I am undecided about if I should go with cake or cookies.  I have to get the order in by tomorrow. 

The first option is a big cookie with the happy birthday message on it, and then individual cookies (they are 3 inch cookies) for all the guests.

The second option is a sheet cake. 

Which do you think would be cuter?  I am doing the Winter Onederland theme and would have the cookies and sheet cake decorated with snowflakes.

Thank you!

EcoBaby

I think it would be hard to bust into a cookie cake!

You can still do cookies for the guests if you want.

TimingisEverything

I would do a cake.

flutterz77

I would do a cake since it's for her 1st Birthday! She has to smash it and get all messy and can't do that with a cookie. I would do the smaller cookies to match the cake it you wanted.

jamie4duke

Thank you!  Cake it is!  I knew I could count on my bumpies for help. 

susanmosley

i think cookies would be cute.