I was reading a collection of letters from an Ohio pioneer from this period and I jotted down the names (no SSA for this period!) if you're interested. Here's the list of the names that came up in her letters:
Girls: Boys:
Anna Joseph
Hannah William Henry
Maria Isaac
Deborah Franklin
Aliceanna Granville
Ann Thomas
Sarah Robert
Susan Nathan
Margaret Seth
Elizabeth William
Mary Harmon
Sally Morris
Peggy Moses
Polly Edward
Eliza Aaron
Dorothy Ellis
Dolly Caleb
Phoebe Jehu
Fanny Joshua
Catharine Abia
Jessie Sammy
Helen Marcus
Jason
Levi
George
Charles
Gerard
Richard
Curry
Asa
Men's/Boy's names seemed to be much more diverse than women's. There were so many different Sarahs, Anns, Elizabeths, etc!
Re: Somes names from 1826-1858
Eliza and Isaac are my favorites from these!