I chose the color one because the black and white one looks washed out.. But, you may want to futz around a bit with the black and white image. If you up the contrast and down the brightness, you might get an image with more depth and might like it better.
I think I like the color one based on the color photo you have. If your DS was wearing something else, or the colors on the invite were different, I might like the b/w better.
Either way, it's adorable and that's a great picture of your DS.
Re: PIP & POLL
LOVE the invitation!
I can't see the color, but I like the B&W with that invite.
*tear* are their birthdays really so close?!
I think I like the color one based on the color photo you have. If your DS was wearing something else, or the colors on the invite were different, I might like the b/w better.
Either way, it's adorable and that's a great picture of your DS.