American Idol Watchers (maybe Spoiler)

Nick Strafella

Am I the only one who thinks Scott is NOT that good of a singer???? DH keeps saying I am wrong, and obviously America likes him because he is still on the show...but I think he is BAD!! Is he getting the votes because people feel bad for him??

Mominator

I don't think that he is bad per se, but he's no American Idol, kwim?

*Bre*

I think he is REALLY not good. Always have.

Tonight, my pic is Allison. I think my Anoop Dawg did well, however. I think that Kris and the first piano guy may be in trouble and I want stupid Michael Sarver's butt GONE

Mandy06

Yeah I don't think he is that great either. He obviously has talent, but I don't think he is the next American Idol.

Now Adam on the other hand. That boy has major talent. I thought he was great tonight.

PMJacobsen

i think he is a good piano player, but that's it. and i think if he wasn't blind, he wouldn't be this far. flame if you wish, i really don't care tonight who i offend.

misscindycake

DH and I both agree that if we had a friend that sang like Scott he'd be "awesome" but he really needs to be voted off the show.  It's just painful to watch!

On Best Week Ever Paul F. Tompkins issued a heartfelt statement to Scott about how wonderful and inspirational he is while holding up signs that said: "Just because he is a blind man doesn't mean you have to act deaf".