Looking for girl name suggestions

satsumasandlemons

would love suggestions for this girl - I'm looking for slightly quirky names that aren't too unique but definitely not top 20. 
Some names I like include Margot, Matilda, Willa, piper, and Hattie. Clementine and juniper are too whimsical for me. 
Sibling is Carly. 

Thanks in advance!

FakeFinn

How about Beatrice, Juno or Sybil?

mb0112

Beatrice
Phoebe
Nelly
Vera
Thea
Eloise 
Mabel
Fiona 

ashleyandely

Love Margot and Piper

Nadia
Daphne
Polly
Veda
Winter
Astrid
Iris 

emilyalso

Love Margot and Hattie! 

Hazel
Fern 
Liza
Millie
Olive

Gators&BoSox

Love Margot. I like Hattie but as a NN for Harriet. Suggesting

Bernadette
Alice
Florence
Talia
Teagan
Paige

Bringmemylongswordho

Nadine
Minerva 
Doris
Zelda
Colleen 

MamaWren919

I love Piper and Hattie. Kind of spunky, but not too out there, where it just seems like you're trying too hard. Also suggest Willow or Stella.

sqfibemom

Ramona
Lena
Arwen/Arden/Adair/Auden
Alice
Calliope
Eloise
Arrow
Lark/Lake/Laken
Oak/Oakley/Oaklin
Meadow
Sadie
Rose/Rosalie
Poet
Adelaide
Millie
Penelope

mrs_tacos

Of the names you listed, Hattie and Willa are my favorites with Carly. Of those suggested by pp, I like Phoebe, Hazel, and Alice.

Ada

Audra

Autumn

Brenna

Brynn

Edith

Eliza

Evelyn

Georgia

Imogen

Ingrid

Lydia

Mae

Mila

Natalie

Rose

Sylvia

Tessa

satsumasandlemons

Thanks guys! I'd always welcome more suggestions but there are some great names here to start with. i especially love Audra and Ada, Lydia, and Millie. 

4N6s

Carys, elowyn 

satsumasandlemons

Hi there, bumping this back for some more help - I learned the hard way that we should probably not welcome feedback from 5 yr old future big sisters because she not only hates the name Margot, she is gunning for names like Rosetta (from Tinker Bell) and Neveah. 

What's the consensus on Elliott for a girl? We've been toying with the idea of using the one boy name we've had forever for this girl. No gender (sex) disappointment here, just always sure of the boy name. We'd nn her Lottie or Ellie or something.  

Bringmemylongswordho

I hate Elliott for a girl. It's a masculine name.  There are plenty of feminine names that give the nickname ellie or lottie. Everyone always cites Elliott from Scrubs as a reason to use it, except was a huge plot point that she was named Elliott because her dad wanted a son, and she spent so much of her life trying to live up to his expectations.  

joforyoga

I like Elliott for a girl. I know one and she's adorable and her Mom does not regret the name choice. She said she doesn't get made fun of because it's more common now anyways to see unisex or boys names on girls and she said her daughter loves that no one else in her school has her name. I would for sure go with Lottie over Ellie though, I fell like that nn is super overdone.

ashleyandely

Also despise Elliott on a girl. But I hate the boy name on girl trend in general. Its the effing worst. 

bbiutmcph

Ugh hate Elliot or the dreaded Elliotte on a girl. So trendy and unoriginal not to mention Ellie is even more trendy and yawnworthy.

 

Bringmemylongswordho

Oh. And because I am a dirty lurker, I saw your post in the July baby names thread. 

Rose isn't the root of Rosalind,  it's Hros (ancient Germanic for horse). In English the spelling influenced by the Latin "rosa linda" but the names origin and meaning has nothing to do with rose. 

Also Roz is 10 times better a nn then Elle/Ellie. (Lottie is pretty cool,  Roz is only twice as good as Lottie)

satsumasandlemons

so what do you really think of the name, dirty lurker?
i really don't like the nn ellie either, i definitely prefer lottie, and thanks for the etymology lesson. 

i appreciate the feedback, i certainly want to avoid using a name that is as potentially cringeworthy as neveah, so this was very helpful! the search continues... 

FakeFinn

I'm on the no to Elliott/Elliotte/Eliette team. 

Rosalind nn Roz or Rosa is awesome.