Infertility

Cost Effectiveness of Various Infertility Treatments

In a few separate posts, I've talked about how my husband & I evaluated our IF treatment options by looking at how cost effective they were.  I thought I'd start a separate thread to explain the math we used and share the data.   

Please note that all data is assuming normal tubes, no endo, no MFI, and 2+ years of TTC.  

Results:

Analysis of Results:

  • Cost per % represents the amount of money paid for each percentage point of 'success.'  Lower = more cost effective.
  • Treatments in order of cost effectiveness
  • Based on the above data - we decided that for us, IUI (with no medication), IUI (with injectables), and TI (with injectables) were not cost effective enough to pursue, when compared to the other available options.  
Assumptions:
  • Cost - I used the following estimates.  The order of magnitude of the cost is significant, the specific dollar amount is not.  For example, it does not impact the relative effectiveness if oral meds cost $10 instead of $50, or if IUI costs $750 instead of $500.   

  • % Success - I took data from the below table (and extrapolated where necessary), assuming total motile sperm count over 20 million.

Disclaimer: We're both engineers with MBAs - so we tend to make very data driven decisions.  Although that works for us, it's definitely necessarily the best decision for everyone.  So many other factors play a part in IF than just dollars and cents, do what's right for you!
Me (31) & DH (31) - married 2008; TTC since 2013
SA = normal; HSG = clear; history of DVT/PE
Diagnosed with unexplained infertility
IUI #1- April '16 - BFN 
IUI #2 - May '16 - BFN
IVF Fresh Xfer #1 (1 blastocyst) - Sept '16 - BFN
FET #2 - 11/8/16 (2 blastocysts) - Beta on 11/18
4 more blastocysts on ice
LadyMillilConstanceGoodspeed

Re: Cost Effectiveness of Various Infertility Treatments

  • Wow! You two sure did your homework! I'm curious where you got your prices for each different type from. I'm assuming you have full insurance coverage for at least of few of these, as the actual cost of an IUI cycle with meds for me is closer to $1200 with all the monitoring.
    About us:
    Me - 27, Lean PCOS
    DH - 30
    Married June 2010, TTC since March 2014
    Blog: ourbinarystar.com

    FET cycle #3 Transfer July 28th 2016, Triplets born healthy on February 26th 2017 at 33w1d!

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards