Baby Girl #3

jkolber10

Our first two daughters are Emily and Caroline. We're looking for another classic, three-syllable name for their baby sister coming in May. Other suggestions welcome.

breezycat

I like all of them but I voted for Jillian. All great choices but I might scratch Natalie off the list because it sort of rhymes with Emily.

Suggest: Caroline, Emily and

Julia
Sabrina
Tabitha
Isabelle
Gwendolyn
Rebecca

BlueJuice

I really really like Natalie, but I voted for Abigail because it seems to flow better with your sibling set as it stands. 

SmrBrd2012

I voted Natalie bc I think it goes best with your sibset but I also really like Samantha.

esca18

I voted Jillian. Lydia is NMS but I think all your other names are great!

g8trkim

I voted Abigail but I like Natalie a lot too.

KaLikeAWind

I voted Abigail but I like Samantha too

fghmama6701

Samantha is my favorite but I like Abigail too.

Rshapiro86

Samantha!

Karenin

I picked Abigail but wanted to say they are all great and I love your first two DDs names! Natalie is my least favorite here but all of them work.

scotten

I voted Samantha, because that's my name. It's a good one!

virginiaunicorn11

If you plan to call Abigail "Abby" (choose your favorite spelling, whatever) then it may not flow as well with Emily. But it's my favorite on your list.

(And maybe the whole point of sticking with three syllables is you aren't doing two-syllable nicknames, so maybe it's a moot point.)

jkolber10

Thank you everyone!! Good suggestions, I really appreciate it.

LNic5

I like Jillian the best...not super common and goes well with your daughters names

wlr1030

I love Abigail! It's my favorite from your list. I really like Lydia too. Natalie is a nice name but I don't like how Emily and Natalie both end with the "lee" sound.

SkiChic626

You have two somewhat regal names.  What about keeping with that tradition?  Elizabeth, Alice, Alexandra, Charlotte, Kathryn, Sarah, Margaret