I *think* we have narrowed our boy name search down to a select few first names. However, matching them with a middle name is a whole new challenge. All of the middle names are family names.
Eugene (my father who passed when I was just six weeks pregnant)
Love all names listed! I voted Gideon because I just like how fresh it feels (classic but I don't hear it often). It was honestly a toss up, though, because I love all three names. I also really like all three MNs, but I chose Eugene since it was your father's name. I don't think you could go wrong with any combination listed above, but Gideon Eugene had such an impressive ring to it, and I like the connection to your father's memory it evokes.
I've never been a huge fan of the name Scott but Gideon Scott has incredible cadence. Depending on your last name, that might be one of the most harmonious sounding name combinations I've heard on this site yet.
Re: boy name combos