Top two girls names, help please!

cives2012

We've narrowed it down to Jane and Lucy as first names. Thoughts? We already have a middle name, so we just need to decide on the first name. 

bbiutmcph

What is the middle name?

cives2012

It's a family name, both sound great with it, that's why we took it off to get opinions of just the first names.  

erinnlou

Personally love Jane as a first name.

benmel31

Lucy

eliztheforrizz

Love both. I can't really give one the edge without knowing the middle name.

katrinasmith17

Jane classic and beautiful

gonetothesea

Jane is a lovely and underused first name. Would love to hear the mn when you decide on the fn!

eileenmcgoo

Haha! Both of my girls have those names! Love them both!

ashleyandely

Jane.

mattandlora

I like both names, but I'm seeing Lucy used a lot more right now. I'd say Jane, to have something different

crf4

Jane. I don't know why but I Love Lucy just turns me off of the name since it'll probably always be referenced.

slradske0626

Jane! I think it will age much better and is definitely underused.

trudytudy

Jane is on my list! Wonderful name! Lucy is cute but doesn't suit a grown up as well in my opinion.

Elsa1984

Not knowing the middle name you are going to use, I would have to say Jane. But that is only because I love the nn Lucy, but I don't like Lucy as a full name....

groovylocks

Oh man these are BOTH two of my favourite names. (My spirit animal, you!) 

Ugh... ok i'll give you the reasons I like both. 

Lucy I've never met a lucy i didn't like. It means "Light" which is fantastic. Lucys tend, in my experience, to be extroverts, funny, friendly and quirky. And one of the Lucys i know is an older lady and it suits her wonderfully.

Jane.. oh Jane. Classic, beautiful Jane. All the janes i've ever known have either been very dignified and elegant or very unique and punky. Either way, great associations. 

So the people with those names are the reasons i love those names so much.