Too similar?

jburdet1

Sylvia nn Sylvie and big sister, Shelby Kate?

Clara and big sister, Isla?

Thanks!  

firsttimeauntie

I don't think Sylvie is not too close to Shelby Kate. Since Shelby Kate is a double name it takes away the similarity for me. Is that weird? lol I think if you are going to call her Sylvie just name her that. I don't really see it as a nn.

Clara and Isla are kind of similar but I think it just might be the "a" ending so I think it's ok.

KTZ17

Sylvie and Shelby are pretty close, but like PP said if you always call Shelby Kate by both names, it's not that bad. I don't see anything similar about Clara and Isla besides the ending, and I love Clara!!

ProfessorMcGonagall

I think it is too close

jburdet1

ProfessorMcGonagall said:

I think it is too close

Both?

DaisyZH

I don't think either are too similar, they are both very sweet names.

emoxymoose

Wait. I'm confused, is this for your future children?

nittanyllama

I think Sylvie is too close to Shelby, even though it's an adorable name!

Clara works great with your sibset!

Jennifer2008

I think any of them work together just fine

julesgilead

Clara is fine, but Sylvie and Shelby seem a little sing-songy to me.

PB&J714

I'm on the fence with Shelby and Sylvie. I LOVE Sylvie, but I'm thinking that it miiight be a little too similar to Shelby. Clara sounds awesome with the sibset!

Ceridwen21

Both are too close for my taste.

Belle3184

I love the double name Shelby Kate.

I don't think Sylvia is too close.

jburdet1

emoxymoose said:

Wait. I'm confused, is this for your future children?

Yes, for possible future children. 

I'm baby name obsessed so I like to keep my lists updated

LisaG09

I think Clara and Isla are too close but if Shelby is always Shelby Kate then I think Sylvia nn Sylvie is adorable. Sylvia is at the top of my future children's name list too.

emoxymoose

I like Clara and Sylvia. But I don't think either are too close to be used together.

this decaf life

Sylvia and Shelby are too close IMO. I love the NN Sylvie though but yes, too close.

I don't think Clara and Isla are too close but I don't really like the name Clara.