Warning **SS** Names Poll: Sorry but I'm desperate!

LilyGracesMommy

So DH and I are deciding between Eve and Rose for this LOs name... I have been posting on the baby names board multiple times, and while those ladies are super helpful I wanted to poll my BMB...
MNs are up in the air but we like Madeline, Annalise our LN starts with a hard K sound and is 2 syllables

This all being said DS is James and DD is Lily and while I still like Rose, many posters on the baby names board felt it was too matchy ( my worry) while others loved the name, or liked it more than Eve so they said to still use it...

Well I made the mistake of making our name choices public to DHs family and his sisters dislike Eve (reminds them of a fat German?)and his grandma says it makes her puke... ( real nice right...) So I'm torn, while I don't care as much about his family's reactions ( bc I know they'll love the baby whatever her name) he is more swayed....

So Im asking your opinions, and yes I know I'm being a SS but I feel like I've been hashing over names so much lately that I may go insane...

Sareynoo

I like all of them but my favorite would be Rose Annalise..

rileymiller

Ignore the inlaws. You're right, they will love her no matter the name. My opinion, but I prefer Eve. I am not fond of the town middle name choices with Eve you posted, but I actually think Eve Rose K sounds nice!

gregsgurl81304

I like them both, but I vote Eve because I think of Rose as more of a middle name, but that's my personal preference. Good luck.