It seems like tons of women want a girl that they can have a bond with and be close with when they're grown. But irl, I don't know, it seems like more girls have that sort of bond with their fathers to me.
Most Moms and daughters I know have a lot of ups and downs in their relationship as mutual adults, and some flat out don't get along. It just strikes me as strange that young women continually idealize that mother and daughter relationship, given frequent proof in their own lives that these things rarely turn out perfectly
.
Re: s/o Do you think the mother/daughter relationship is overidealized?
I was a daddy's girl when I was younger but as a young woman and now grown woman am hands down closer to my mom. I think it's easier for mothers/daughters to tolerate the ups and downs in their relationship (I totally have this with my mom) but I think it's because we're so much alike we respond the same way. I am not like my father at all so when we argue we argue differently and there's a strain on our relationship for awhile, whereas with my mom we get over it quicker and are more understanding of each other.
I wouldn't know what to do without my mother and I hope my daughter feels that way about me someday.
I am one of those that bonded with Dad and have a very complicated relationship with Mom. This was one of the primary reasons that I was really hoping for a son.
I never really realized just how much of a buffer my Dad provided between my Mom and myself until he passed away 6 years ago.
I know it's not isolated to me, because my sister interacts with her even less than I do.
Obviously, you don't get to choose the gender of your child, and my husband and I are having a daughter. It scares me that I really don't know what my Mom did to make our relationship so difficult, so I really don't even feel like I can learn from her mistakes.
I would say my dad and more "friends" than my mom and i are, but i think ours is a special snowflake situation.
My mom is an identical twin and no one has ever been closer to my mom than her twin. They are like one person.
My dad and i are a LOT alike and understand each other very well.
I'm close with my mom, my sister is not. I love my dad, but I can talk easier with my mom.
The bond my mom and I share isn't enough for me to "want" a particular gender/sex.
I think the most important thing is to be a good and open parent. DH and his mom are close, and he's a boy.
BFP #3 via cancelled IUI ~ C (2lb 3oz; HELLP) 5/16/11
BFP #4 via the natural (free!) way ~ E (8lb 11oz) 9/13/12
My mom is my best friend. I love my Dad, and I'm really close with him as well, but I do have an awesome relationship with my mother.
I certainly hope my daughter and I will have the same relationship her Nana and I have, but I also know that takes work (esp. in the teenage years) and a lot of willingness on the part of the mom to be flexible and let your daughter be who she is. I think often moms have this expectation of how it WILL be when it comes to their daughters and want too much of their girls, and that leads to friction. I'm like my mom in a lot of ways, and different from her in many others, and she was willing to roll with that and adjust as I was growing up.
My mom supported me and encouraged me to be myself, and I think that's why we are as close as we are today. From the experience of many of my friends, their mothers just were not capable of that, and it has hurt their relationships.
I have no relationship with my mother. She is toxic to me and is not part of my life anymore.
I also see a lot of posts where women wish for a daughter because they think they are going to be so close, do all the "girly" things together, etc, and I think they are setting themselves up for disappointment.
I have a daughter and I'd much rather see her nurturing her mind that dressing up like a princess and getting her nails done all the time.
Me - DX Hashimoto's Disease, Hypothyroid, Rheumatoid Arthritis
DH - DX Azoospermia - Sertoli Cell Syndrome
DS-IUI #1-4 BFN IVF #1 - BFP! It's a boy!!!
I was very much a Daddy's girl growing up and fought with my mom all the time. I now relate a lot more to my Mom but we still butt heads whereas my Dad and I have never been that way.
I have to say one of my irrational pet peeves is women really hoping for a girl so they can have some pie in the sky relationship with their daughter.
I am very close with my mother, I am super lucky we have a lot in common, she even buys me work clothes boxes them and ships them to me b/c she knows my taste and decorated our guest room from 400 miles away. She spent the better part of my childhood driving me thousands of miles to horse competitions and lots of hours in the car together discussing the meaning of life and everything under the sun. We have had our minor ups and downs. We are close but she is not my best friend, she is my mom. If I have a girl, I am not looking for anything different than I have with her. I don't want my child, male or female to be my best friend. I know that in all likelihood they are going to be very different from me and I need to respect that.
All that said, I am my father's daughter. We share the same laid back personality and are super close. I wouldn't say I am daddy's girl at all we just simply relate on a certain level because we are similar.
I am closer to my father because of how much like him I am. While my mother and father have a wonderful relationship, the parts of me that are like her make our relationship less close. That being said, I have a great relationship with my entire family because they are awesome!
I think that sometimes one set is closer than another down a family tree. My mother was closer to her mother than we are, and her sister was closer to her father. Now, my aunt and cousin are super close, while my mother and I are not as close. I wouldn't be surprised if my daughter and I are more alike while my cousin might have a bit of a closer relationship with her son (who is like a mini her). I think people get used to roles, and that can affect those types of relationships.
No, I don't think it's overidealized. I think those who have wonderful relationships want to replicate that with their own daughters, and those who may have had rocky relationships want the chance at something better.
My mom and I have a wonderful relationship. There is nothing in the world like a mother's love, comfort, and support. I would never talk to my dad about the things I talk to my mom about. I can't wait to have that bond with my daughter.
Wedding/Honeymoon Pictures </a>
I get what you're saying. But who's to say you and DD will get along the same way you and your Mom did. You are talking about different people.
Sure. But the same can be said of any parent-child relationship. Daddy's girls will not always be close with their sons, either. But my point was, in answering the original question, no, in my experience, the mother/daughter relationship is not overidealized. In my experience, it has been an amazing relationship, and of course I'm going to project those same feelings onto my own daughter.
I don't think it is, necessarily. Women relate more easily to girls. Even if you have a classic mama's boy, when it comes to the big issues (puberty, dating, sex, etc), they'll more than likely be talking to their father, and not their mother. That's not to say their contributions don't help mold their sons', they surely do! However, some feel left out when it comes to the big issues later on. Even relating to how boys interact with their friends can prove trying.
Not to mention the fact some women relive their childhood/teenage years through their daughters. Not necessarily in a bad way, like pushing their dreams onto their children, but in that.. They remember their experiences, and when they see their child faced with them, they want to make sure the child handles it well if they themselves did not. Women want to nurture, give wisdom, and all of that. It's far easier to do so when you've been through the situations, and often time with boys they haven't.
And when they get older, and it comes time for relationships, girls look to their mothers whether they realize it or not. It may be that they want to be in a loving marriage like their mother, or that they saw what NOT to do and don't want a bad relationship like their mother. But either way, they relate more easily.
Personally, I initially wanted a boy. After going over genetically inherited health risks with my doctor, I had hoped for a girl. And up until last month, the hope for a girl was strong! But honestly.. if I ever do have a girl, and she's anything but a tomboy, I will never relate LOL. I wasn't a princess, barbie, frilly, dress-wearing girl. I never will be. I was the girl that gave her sister's barbies mohawks, and played drums and guitar, trying my damnedest to be in my brother's band haha.
Even though my father wasn't around, I've always bonded better with men. Growing up, all of my friends were boys. I was never interested in gossiping, hair, make up, or any of the usual girly things. I had a few friends that were girls, but only the ones considered to not "fit in," as around here, if you're an intelligent woman that doesn't play ditzy to make the man feel dominant, you weren't normal. So, I could never relate to those things. However, I am my mother. And I respect her for all of her good qualities. And when the time comes when I need advice, I always go to her. We were never close, hell my family isn't even a hugging family. But, I've always felt that if I needed guidance, she was the one to provide it.
I have to say I totally disagree here.
I find women to generally be more judgmental, and men more easy going. Whenever I needed advice, I always went to my dad because my mother was always wrapped up in emotion and self centered thinking rather than what the real issue was.
"What will everyone think" was more on my mom's mind than actual advice.
EDT: Also on the point about whether they know it or not they go to their mom for dating advice.. I keep my mom as far out of my personal business as possible. So that is also incorrect.
My mother and I have a great relationship. She was always loving and nuturing. I also have 2 sister and they also have a great relationship with our mother. We are all very close, tight knit family and I would love to have that with my daughter. I would also like my daughter to have sisters like I did because they are my best friends!
I have an amazing bond with both parents. I was an only child. It's a different kind of bond. Yes, I do call my Mom for everything and any advice I need and secretly seek her advice and approval and if something is bothering me she can make me feel better like no one else. Even when I am sick I tell DH that I want my Mom to take care of me because she does it best. I hope to be just like her. She is no Mary Poppins or Mother Hubbard either but she was perfect for me. She's never been pushy and has always encouraged me to make my own decisions without giving input unless I asked for it.
My Dad and I have a perfect Father/Daughter relationship but I don't tell him everything like do mostly with my Mom. Then again there are certain things I'd rather talk with my Dad about too. I would say that at almost 26 years old he spoils me rotten still. I am on bedrest right now and he is over here most getting my mail and bringing me food.
BLOG
I have a great relationship with both my mom and my dad, but my dad is a more difficult person, so there have been times (i.e. puberty and adolescence, mostly) when we did struggle, though we are best friends now. With my mom, though, I hardly ever fought. And we are very different women...
I wanted a little girl - and I'm getting one, yey! - but I will aim for a little boy in the next one (I'm having at least two kids in any case), because I want the whole experience. I didn't want a girl because my relationship with my own mom is so great, or because I think it will all be a paradise of hair braiding and shoeshopping. I want a girl because I was once a little girl too and I want to witness that transformation from girl to woman I went through in someone else. And I want a little boy because I want to see his transformation from boy to man up close, since I haven't experienced anything like that first hand. And hopefully I'll be able to help both of them along the way, or just hold their hands when they need or ask me to.
So no, I don't think the mother/daughter relationship is overidealized, at least not anymore than the mother/son relationship is - and the latter can be just as crappy just as often... I just think we all have kids hoping that we'll get along wonderfully with them and, sadly, it doesn't always happen that way.
All the best!
This. Although I know there are many mother/daughter relationships that are rocky because of different reasons, I don't think it's overidealized.
My mom is my absolute best friend. She's usually the first person I think of when I want to tell ANYONE something. We are super close. I am also extremely blessed to have an amazing relationship with my dad. He's also someone I tell pretty much everything too.
I think it all depends on how you raise your daughter OR son that makes your relationship.
I think that women prefer to have a daughter for other reasons though, not just a close "mother-daughter" relationship.
I grew up in a family of women. My mom was a single mom (and while I am close to my dad, I don't remember him ever living with us) and my only sibling is a sister. I was raised in a house with all women, and now I have a daughter.
While ultimately I want a healthy child above all else, of course I would absolutely love to have another daughter, because girls are basically all I've ever known. I also would love for my DD to grow up with a sister the way I did. DH also wants another girl so bad.
natural m/c and d&c at 10 weeks - 1/24/2014
DX w/ hetero C677t and A1298C MTHFR - 3/4/2014
Yeah, my dad was my fave. I didn't fully appreciate my mother until I met my MIL. I thought she was so lame and dumb that my mother suddenly shone like an angel.
I specifically am keeping things like the baby names and sex secret from the MIL this time. It is a sure way to not hear an opinion from her or get bombarded with gifts I don't like (it sounds bad, but she has bad taste). She's just a weirdo!
Hope your relationship with your mom gets better! It's never perfect, but I have my moments with mine. I wouldn't trade her.