Babies: 6 - 9 Months

A Christmas Ethics Question

Alright, so DD is #5 out of 6 of my inlaws' grandchildren.  Each year we gather around a living room full of presents here the kids go insane and don't seem to appreciate much less remember half of what they got that morning.  When DH and I got married we agreed when we had children we would limit all the aunts and uncles to two presents from each family (one from them and one from the cousins).  She has 7, so that's more than plenty in my mind.  My SIL has become upset by our rule because she believe it will not be fair to DD to watch all the other children open up a bunch of presents while she has one per person.  

 A) I want my daughter to grow up appreciating what she receives and I haven't limited birthdays, or if they feel like gifting throughout the year, so I am I wrong by limiting Christmas?

B) I know some of my siblings will neglect what we'd like and get Rohan multiple presents anyways.  What do we do with the others in order to not seem ungrateful?

 TIA 

«1

Re: A Christmas Ethics Question

  • Unfortunately you already look ungrateful by telling them how many gifts they can get.

    Gifts are gifts and you should not tell people how many they can get your kids.  

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I don't really think you can tell people how many gifts to get your DD, but what you can do is keep the number of gifts that you think is fair, and then donate the rest to a toy drive.

  • Loading the player...
  • Just let your family give your kid the gifts.  You really will end up treating your child unfairly in the future, because she will watch all of her cousins get way more gifts.
  • imageyankeebaby2:

    Unfortunately you already look ungrateful by telling them how many gifts they can get.

    Gifts are gifts and you should not tell people how many they can get your kids.  

    this. leave it alone.

    aidan kincaid (12.19.06) sawyer grace (7.30.08) 
    reese madeline (5.11.10) miller paige (2.6.12)
    girl #5 due december 2013.



    13 galveston1



    IG: punkfictionv4

  • My thought process behind it is to focus on Christmas without the gifts.  My nieces and nephews couldn't even tell you the point of Christmas, and I grew up without the whole gift giving craziness, and I don't feel like I was unjustly raised because of it.  I want Rohan's Christmas focus to be on family, being together, and helping those in need, especially since we're blessed enough to have Daddy home from deployment for Christmas.
  • you are annoying. this is not ethical. youre rude. its rude to tell people how many gifts your kid can get if they want to buy them for him. grow some balls and be a mom every OTHER day of the year and teach him appreciation. then, on xmas, he will understand.
    aidan kincaid (12.19.06) sawyer grace (7.30.08) 
    reese madeline (5.11.10) miller paige (2.6.12)
    girl #5 due december 2013.



    13 galveston1



    IG: punkfictionv4

  • imagelilwyhunter33:
    My thought process behind it is to focus on Christmas without the gifts.  My nieces and nephews couldn't even tell you the point of Christmas, and I grew up without the whole gift giving craziness, and I don't feel like I was unjustly raised because of it.  I want Rohan's Christmas focus to be on family, being together, and helping those in need, especially since we're blessed enough to have Daddy home from deployment for Christmas.

    Receiving gifts and appreciating the meaning of Christmas are not mutually exclusive.  Stress the meaning of Christmas to her.

    But seriously.  Drop it with your family.  You are being really rude.

  • imagelilwyhunter33:
    My thought process behind it is to focus on Christmas without the gifts.  My nieces and nephews couldn't even tell you the point of Christmas, and I grew up without the whole gift giving craziness, and I don't feel like I was unjustly raised because of it.  I want Rohan's Christmas focus to be on family, being together, and helping those in need, especially since we're blessed enough to have Daddy home from deployment for Christmas.

    why not just reenact  the Christmas Carol instead of opening gifts then?

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagelilwyhunter33:
    My thought process behind it is to focus on Christmas without the gifts.  My nieces and nephews couldn't even tell you the point of Christmas, and I grew up without the whole gift giving craziness, and I don't feel like I was unjustly raised because of it.  I want Rohan's Christmas focus to be on family, being together, and helping those in need, especially since we're blessed enough to have Daddy home from deployment for Christmas.

    If you don't like the way they celebrate Christmas with the copious gift giving, then don't go. If you do go, don't expect to limit the # of gifts they do get your DD. You can instill in your DD the true meaning of Christmas regardless of what gifts she receives, and in what number. Like I mentioned before, have her donate the majority of her gifts to those who are less fortunate if you are wanting to stress that spirit of Christmas is more than receiving gifts, but it is also helping those in need.

  • or the nativity :)
    aidan kincaid (12.19.06) sawyer grace (7.30.08) 
    reese madeline (5.11.10) miller paige (2.6.12)
    girl #5 due december 2013.



    13 galveston1



    IG: punkfictionv4

  • imageyankeebaby2:

    Unfortunately you already look ungrateful by telling them how many gifts they can get.

    Gifts are gifts and you should not tell people how many they can get your kids.  

    This. Trust me, I get not wanting DD to get a ton of stuff. We have the same problem. But its really rude to tell people they can't get your child gifts (or to limit)

  • yeah, i'm with everyone else. teach our lo what christmas is really about, but don't tell people how many gifts they can get for your child. it's a GIFT. appreciate it. you should be glad you have family that cares about your child and spoils them!

    it's all about how you raise your child, and if you raise them to appreciate what they have, they will. i got tons of presents when i was little and i can tell you what i got almost every year to this day.... and i know what christmas is about!

  • I didn't realize it would be so offensive?  I thought it would be ruder to take the gifts to a toy drive or something of the sort if there were too many.  With this much opposition to the idea of limiting Christmas I'm curious if there are any Jehovah Witness' or other religions on the boards who could share with me on how they handle not doing Christmas at all?  The whole commercialization of all the holidays has really disappointed me over the las few years, especially now that mommy hood has taken off.  I also didn't realize that my beliefs would be found 'annoying'.  Thank you for your input though, I will take it to heart (and to my husband) and maybe we will reassess. 
  • imagelilwyhunter33:
    I didn't realize it would be so offensive?  I thought it would be ruder to take the gifts to a toy drive or something of the sort if there were too many.  With this much opposition to the idea of limiting Christmas I'm curious if there are any Jehovah Witness' or other religions on the boards who could share with me on how they handle not doing Christmas at all?  The whole commercialization of all the holidays has really disappointed me over the las few years, especially now that mommy hood has taken off.  I also didn't realize that my beliefs would be found 'annoying'.  Thank you for your input though, I will take it to heart (and to my husband) and maybe we will reassess. 

    Why would it be rude to take the toy to a toy drive?

  • Oh.My.God.  There is nothing wrong with your family giving your child gifts.  If you think the meaning of Christmas is giving, then how will anyone ever give if someone else cannot receive?  It is about BOTH.
  • lmao i realllllly hate people like you around the holidays.
    aidan kincaid (12.19.06) sawyer grace (7.30.08) 
    reese madeline (5.11.10) miller paige (2.6.12)
    girl #5 due december 2013.



    13 galveston1



    IG: punkfictionv4

  • let it be.  you can still instill your values and the importance of christmas even with all the crazy gift giving going on.  you are very lucky.
  • imagemisscharlotte04:

    imagelilwyhunter33:
    I didn't realize it would be so offensive?  I thought it would be ruder to take the gifts to a toy drive or something of the sort if there were too many.  With this much opposition to the idea of limiting Christmas I'm curious if there are any Jehovah Witness' or other religions on the boards who could share with me on how they handle not doing Christmas at all?  The whole commercialization of all the holidays has really disappointed me over the las few years, especially now that mommy hood has taken off.  I also didn't realize that my beliefs would be found 'annoying'.  Thank you for your input though, I will take it to heart (and to my husband) and maybe we will reassess. 

    Why would it be rude to take the toy to a toy drive?

    bc people dont usually like buying presents, thinking about their niece, and then to find out "oh. no. i gave that away before they even played with it since i dont want my child to think xmas is about plastic and noises. i, of course, dont want to teach her that every other day of the year. just on xmas"

    aidan kincaid (12.19.06) sawyer grace (7.30.08) 
    reese madeline (5.11.10) miller paige (2.6.12)
    girl #5 due december 2013.



    13 galveston1



    IG: punkfictionv4

  • imagelilwyhunter33:
    I didn't realize it would be so offensive?  I thought it would be ruder to take the gifts to a toy drive or something of the sort if there were too many.  With this much opposition to the idea of limiting Christmas I'm curious if there are any Jehovah Witness' or other religions on the boards who could share with me on how they handle not doing Christmas at all?  The whole commercialization of all the holidays has really disappointed me over the las few years, especially now that mommy hood has taken off.  I also didn't realize that my beliefs would be found 'annoying'.  Thank you for your input though, I will take it to heart (and to my husband) and maybe we will reassess. 

    were you this sanctimonious before you got PG or after you had tiny tim? 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagepunkfiction_v.3:
    lmao i realllllly hate people like you around the holidays.

    me too.  the kind of people who don't even give the homeless a dollar any other day but volunteer at the soup kitchen on Thanksgiving day. 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • At this age, I wouldn't think that it really matters, and would just allow people to buy what they want to.  When your baby is older, and understands a little bit more, try this to reinforce appreciation:

    After the gifts are open, explain that he/she will get the presents after a thanks you card is written for each one.  A coworker at work didthis with her children, and even as college students they still refrain from enjoying their gifts too much before writing a thanks you.

    image pregnancy calendar Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • OP: I have a three year old (he turns 4 twelve days after Christmas) and he is showered with gifts every year. We have a rule though, only one person opens a gift at a time so everyone can appreciate everyone else's gifts. It takes a long time, but everyone feels special.

    He knows the religious reason behind Christmas (DH is religious, I'm agnostic, but I still respect the "reason for the season").

    Your nieces and nephews sound like they are victims of crappy parenting.

     

    This is a test. This is only a test.
  • I really think you should let it go and the take a step back and appreciate the fact that you have so many people that care about your kid. 

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagepunkfiction_v.3:
    imagemisscharlotte04:

    imagelilwyhunter33:
    I didn't realize it would be so offensive?  I thought it would be ruder to take the gifts to a toy drive or something of the sort if there were too many.  With this much opposition to the idea of limiting Christmas I'm curious if there are any Jehovah Witness' or other religions on the boards who could share with me on how they handle not doing Christmas at all?  The whole commercialization of all the holidays has really disappointed me over the las few years, especially now that mommy hood has taken off.  I also didn't realize that my beliefs would be found 'annoying'.  Thank you for your input though, I will take it to heart (and to my husband) and maybe we will reassess. 

    Why would it be rude to take the toy to a toy drive?

    bc people dont usually like buying presents, thinking about their niece, and then to find out "oh. no. i gave that away before they even played with it since i dont want my child to think xmas is about plastic and noises. i, of course, dont want to teach her that every other day of the year. just on xmas"

    I guess I'm a sneaky b then, cause I would just donate and not tell them. Kind of like, if the toy wasn't something LO wanted/needed, I would exchange it for something else and not tell them...or regift. I figure it would be better than arguing over how many gifts they could get LO.

  • imagelilwyhunter33:
    My thought process behind it is to focus on Christmas without the gifts.  My nieces and nephews couldn't even tell you the point of Christmas, and I grew up without the whole gift giving craziness, and I don't feel like I was unjustly raised because of it.  I want Rohan's Christmas focus to be on family, being together, and helping those in need, especially since we're blessed enough to have Daddy home from deployment for Christmas.

    I understand where you are coming from.  Let everyone get her gifts when they would like.  If the actual gift is something you find bothersome, deal with it then (e.g. a gun or something).  But, let them shower her with presents.  As her parents, you can teach her that Christmas is Jesus's birthday, and she gets gifts from everyone in celebration of that.  Maybe you can help her make Jesus a birthday gift or something, when she is old enough to understand.  Your neices and nephews lack of awareness about what Christmas is is not due to the # of gifts they receive.

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageHotSauceonaStick:

    OP: I have a three year old (he turns 4 twelve days after Christmas) and he is showered with gifts every year. We have a rule though, only one person opens a gift at a time so everyone can appreciate everyone else's gifts. It takes a long time, but everyone feels special.

    He knows the religious reason behind Christmas (DH is religious, I'm agnostic, but I still respect the "reason for the season").

    Your nieces and nephews sound like they are victims of crappy parenting.

     

    we do this. we've done it since i was little with both sides of the family.

    i'm really not understanding how presents take away from the meaning of christmas. i'm southern baptist, so i get the whole reason for the season. we do a christmas musical/play every year, but presents aren't shunned.

    and yes, i'm thinking it's bad parenting for your nieces and nephew. maybe just try to get them to the do the one at a time thing.

    Pregnancy Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imageakl0506:

    imagelilwyhunter33:
    My thought process behind it is to focus on Christmas without the gifts.  My nieces and nephews couldn't even tell you the point of Christmas, and I grew up without the whole gift giving craziness, and I don't feel like I was unjustly raised because of it.  I want Rohan's Christmas focus to be on family, being together, and helping those in need, especially since we're blessed enough to have Daddy home from deployment for Christmas.

    I understand where you are coming from.  Let everyone get her gifts when they would like.  If the actual gift is something you find bothersome, deal with it then (e.g. a gun or something).  But, let them shower her with presents.  As her parents, you can teach her that Christmas is Jesus's birthday, and she gets gifts from everyone in celebration of that.  Maybe you can help her make Jesus a birthday gift or something, when she is old enough to understand.  Your neices and nephews lack of awareness about what Christmas is is not due to the # of gifts they receive.

    Do you guys sing Happy Birthday to Jesus? My mom used to make us and I was always really embarrassed.  Especially since Jesus' birthday is actually in March and it as changed as a PR move.

     

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagelilwyhunter33:
    I didn't realize it would be so offensive?  I thought it would be ruder to take the gifts to a toy drive or something of the sort if there were too many.  With this much opposition to the idea of limiting Christmas I'm curious if there are any Jehovah Witness' or other religions on the boards who could share with me on how they handle not doing Christmas at all?  The whole commercialization of all the holidays has really disappointed me over the las few years, especially now that mommy hood has taken off.  I also didn't realize that my beliefs would be found 'annoying'.  Thank you for your input though, I will take it to heart (and to my husband) and maybe we will reassess. 

    If there are any Jehovah Witness' on the board most likely their families are also JW and don't celebrate either. JW's would even GO to a family holiday celebration.

    Seriously, you're being rediculous. Your neices and nephews don't appreciate their gifts on Christmas because their PARENTS haven't taught them to appreciate things during the rest of the years. Do you really think this behavior only crops up at Christmas? Doubtful, they're probably spoiled in many ways throughout the year. If you teach your child to appreciate things throughout the year the presents at Christmas will be no issue.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageyankeebaby2:
    imageakl0506:

    imagelilwyhunter33:
    My thought process behind it is to focus on Christmas without the gifts.  My nieces and nephews couldn't even tell you the point of Christmas, and I grew up without the whole gift giving craziness, and I don't feel like I was unjustly raised because of it.  I want Rohan's Christmas focus to be on family, being together, and helping those in need, especially since we're blessed enough to have Daddy home from deployment for Christmas.

    I understand where you are coming from.  Let everyone get her gifts when they would like.  If the actual gift is something you find bothersome, deal with it then (e.g. a gun or something).  But, let them shower her with presents.  As her parents, you can teach her that Christmas is Jesus's birthday, and she gets gifts from everyone in celebration of that.  Maybe you can help her make Jesus a birthday gift or something, when she is old enough to understand.  Your neices and nephews lack of awareness about what Christmas is is not due to the # of gifts they receive.

    Do you guys sing Happy Birthday to Jesus? My mom used to make us and I was always really embarrassed.  Especially since Jesus' birthday is actually in March and it as changed as a PR move.

     

    I thought it was October?

    H's family actually does sing. They get him a bday cake. The little kids love it (its his extended family with all the cousins and their kids). I thought it was cute!

  • imageIrishBrideND:
    imageyankeebaby2:
    imageakl0506:

    imagelilwyhunter33:

    Do you guys sing Happy Birthday to Jesus? My mom used to make us and I was always really embarrassed.  Especially since Jesus' birthday is actually in March and it as changed as a PR move. 

    I thought it was October?

    H's family actually does sing. They get him a bday cake. The little kids love it (its his extended family with all the cousins and their kids). I thought it was cute!

    It was the spring equinox on the Roman Calendar.  They changed it to drum up more interest from the pagans, who were already celebrating the pagan feast of the sun god.  

    It was cute when we were little.  Kind of embarrassing when we were older.  My mom also used birthday paper for christmas and just scribbled in Jesus under the happy birthday.  


    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageyankeebaby2:
    imageIrishBrideND:
    imageyankeebaby2:
    imageakl0506:

    imagelilwyhunter33:

    Do you guys sing Happy Birthday to Jesus? My mom used to make us and I was always really embarrassed.  Especially since Jesus' birthday is actually in March and it as changed as a PR move. 

    I thought it was October?

    H's family actually does sing. They get him a bday cake. The little kids love it (its his extended family with all the cousins and their kids). I thought it was cute!

    It was the spring equinox on the Roman Calendar.  They changed it to drum up more interest from the pagans, who were already celebrating the pagan feast of the sun god.  

    It was cute when we were little.  Kind of embarrassing when we were older.  My mom also used birthday paper for christmas and just scribbled in Jesus under the happy birthday.  


    Oh I know why they moved Christmas to December. I just had learned a different date for his original bday.

    Yeah, the big kids don't do it. Its  little kids thing. They love it. And I think its a cute way for a quick reminder of what the day is really about. They don't harp on it.

  • imageIrishBrideND:
    imageyankeebaby2:
    imageIrishBrideND:
    imageyankeebaby2:
    imageakl0506:

    imagelilwyhunter33:

    Do you guys sing Happy Birthday to Jesus? My mom used to make us and I was always really embarrassed.  Especially since Jesus' birthday is actually in March and it as changed as a PR move. 

    I thought it was October?

    H's family actually does sing. They get him a bday cake. The little kids love it (its his extended family with all the cousins and their kids). I thought it was cute!

    It was the spring equinox on the Roman Calendar.  They changed it to drum up more interest from the pagans, who were already celebrating the pagan feast of the sun god.  

    It was cute when we were little.  Kind of embarrassing when we were older.  My mom also used birthday paper for christmas and just scribbled in Jesus under the happy birthday.  


    Oh I know why they moved Christmas to December. I just had learned a different date for his original bday.

    Yeah, the big kids don't do it. Its  little kids thing. They love it. And I think its a cute way for a quick reminder of what the day is really about. They don't harp on it.

    We used to do it in Sunday School when I was little. We do the "Happy Birthday, Jesus" cake for Nathan (and now Lily and my niece).

    Now I want to know which of you is right. I know they moved it because of the Pagan holiday, but I never knew the original date.

    This is a test. This is only a test.
  • HotSauce: a quick google says that Yankee is right. They aren't sure, but most biblical scholars think April 17th
  • imageIrishBrideND:
    HotSauce: a quick google says that Yankee is right. They aren't sure, but most biblical scholars think April 17th

    Damn it. I was just coming back to post that.  Wink

    Thanks, Irish!

    This is a test. This is only a test.
  • imageIrishBrideND:
    HotSauce: a quick google says that Yankee is right. They aren't sure, but most biblical scholars think April 17th

    I tried to google but I'm tired and I would never posts a wikipedia reference.   

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagelilwyhunter33:
    I didn't realize it would be so offensive?  I thought it would be ruder to take the gifts to a toy drive or something of the sort if there were too many.  With this much opposition to the idea of limiting Christmas I'm curious if there are any Jehovah Witness' or other religions on the boards who could share with me on how they handle not doing Christmas at all?  The whole commercialization of all the holidays has really disappointed me over the las few years, especially now that mommy hood has taken off.  I also didn't realize that my beliefs would be found 'annoying'.  Thank you for your input though, I will take it to heart (and to my husband) and maybe we will reassess. 

    It's up to you to instill the meaning of Christmas (Christ being born, giving/recieving, etc.), but it's the perogative of family members to decide how/what/who they want to give gifts to.   In our family, gifts are giving - all the cousins pick out gifts to give to their other cousins - they open them....they are giving and recieving.   Appreciation for gifts is something you can teach your child regardless of how much they recieve.

    You don't have to cart all the new gifts off to a toy drive.    What we do is in the winter, we go through Olivia's toys and she picks out ones that are in excellent shape that she thinks another child would enjoy.   We, then, take them to the local Crisis Center.  

  • imagelilwyhunter33:
    My thought process behind it is to focus on Christmas without the gifts.  My nieces and nephews couldn't even tell you the point of Christmas, and I grew up without the whole gift giving craziness, and I don't feel like I was unjustly raised because of it.  I want Rohan's Christmas focus to be on family, being together, and helping those in need, especially since we're blessed enough to have Daddy home from deployment for Christmas.

    I agree with why you want to do this, but i agree with the ladies leave it be. One: be happy that your in-laws are the giving type- it'll help you in the end cost-wise. Mine are the takers, they look and look and will snarl but they wouldn't dare to give back. Two: if duplicates are given go exchange for something else-put it away for another time, or donate it. Three: the meaning of xmas and all it's beauty comes from the parents, church and yes of course your family but you two enforce that everyone else makes it magical on all different levels. JMO  

    imageBabyFetus Ticker BabyName Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I'm really surprised by the vitrol of this thread.  OP, I'm right there with you.  I can't stand all the over-the-top gift buying during the holidays.  Luckily my whole family got sick of it and we cut back years ago.  If everyone's not on the same page, though, there's not a lot you can do.   

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Gawd some of you guys sound more than a little sanctimonious with your "how dare you ruin the miracle of family giving with your attitude towards gifts".  How hypocritical of you.  Also, the comment on how annoying it is when people work in food kitchens on Thanksgiving but not the rest of the year - really?  Do you really think homeless people begrudge their thanksgiving meal because the workers aren't out there the other 364 days of the year?  pff

    The OP never said she only feels this way about excessive gift giving on Christmas and that she doesn't teach humility the rest of the year.  Nice work turning her into a total harpy based on one comment.

    OP - I don't think there is anything wrong with not wanting your kids to get a million presents on Christmas or any other time.  In fact, we had a conversation with my MIL recently about excessive gift giving and asked her to tone it down because we were getting way too much stuff.  However, it sounds like it's not just one person who's doing it but more of the whole family's tradition.  In that case I think it's a good opportunity to teach your kid to be respectful of other people's traditions, even if you don't share their values (or however you want to put that).  I really liked Char's idea on donating the gifts later. 

    You don't have to justify what you do with the gifts once you recieve them, they are yours.  You can just do an annual purge of the kid's toys and donate whichever ones you don't use or need, and it's nobody's business where the original toy came from. 

  • Give me a break....its CHRISTMAS!!  It's the most wonderful day of the year to be a kid.  Why ruin the fun for your DD because you want to be ethically correct! Kids are supposed to tear into the presents and have a ball opening them!!

    Be happy that your family enjoys buying for them.  My inalws write a check to DS every year. What kid enjoys opening an envelope with a check inside?!?! My mother in law is too lazy to go to a toy store and pick out a single toy for him to open.

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"