Baby Names

"Stealing" family names?

My MIL's cousin has four kids, and three of their names are on our list- Thomas (which we will almost definitely use, it's my grandmother's maiden name and we love it), Charlotte, and Louisa. I don't think it would be THAT big of a deal to use one of the same names, but would it be strange if we used more than one? I'm in love with Louisa if we have a girl, maybe even as a MN.

If it matters, they live in the same city (really close to us, actually), but we don't see them super often, maybe every few months at a grad party or casual family thing. It's not like they'll be running around together at Christmas or anything though. 

Married: 8.5.12
Caleb: 10.9.13
imageimageimage

Re: "Stealing" family names?

  • I think you could get away with using one of the names but I'd side eye using more than one.  
    image
  • It might be weird to use more than one as FNs. Thomas as a FN and Louisa as a MN would probably be OK.

    And it would only be weird to use both because they live near by and you see them. I have no idea what my MIL's cousin's kids are named, so I have no idea if I have copied them...

     

     

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • It might be weird to use more than one, but it you love them, you should use them.  Your MIL's cousin is stretching the family connection a bit, in my opinion.  I would hesitate if were a sibling/BIL/SIL that had used the name.

    imageimageimage

    Trying to get knocked up since June 2012 ~ Dx: PCOS

    BFP 7.24.13 ~ EDD 4.2.14 ~ m/c  9.16.13 @ 11w4d

    BFP 5.4.14 ~ EDD 1.12.15 ~ stick little bean!

    TTGP 2013 Best Blog ~ Fruit ~ My BFP Chart 

  • We considered using one of my MILs cousin's boys names. I think using 3 out of their four children's names is definitely strange. One, totally fine. It's unfortunate because maybe you liked the names before you knew them but it would be odd.
  • I agree with PP's you can probably get away with one, but not both as FN's... 
    F'14 June Challenge: Bizarre Gifs
    24 Absolutely Unexplainable GIFs
    image 
    Lilypie - (lv0g)
  • I don't think I would use more than one. Louisa is beautiful by the way.
  • SpookoSpooko
    10000 Comments 250 Answers 500 Love Its Combo Breaker
    member
    Another vote for 1 but not 2+. And I think you're better off using Thomas if you can justify it bc of the family connection.

  • image BootsyLou:
    I think you could get away with using one of the names but I'd side eye using more than one.  

    this

    O 10.08 & MJ 6.10
  • image BlueDot818:
    I agree with PP's you can probably get away with one, but not both as FN's... 

     

    Agreed 



    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
     

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • image BootsyLou:
    I think you could get away with using one of the names but I'd side eye using more than one.  

    This. I also think Thomas and Charlotte are pretty popular, common names, Louisa not as much...so that one may get more of a side eye.

    photo 203b9128-895f-464c-a378-ff73eaf8c1ce_zps4de57ab1.jpg
    Xander, Hayden & Lily 5 1/2 and Jericho 3 My Blog!
  • image BootsyLou:
    I think you could get away with using one of the names but I'd side eye using more than one.  

    Agree.

     Lilypie - (F3i3)
     
     

    Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers


    Daisypath Anniversary tickers
  • I believe MIL's cousin's kids are far enough away in family terms that I wouldn't even care!

    I don't even know my MIL's cousin's kids. Well, wait a minute, my husband knows my mom's cousin's kids and I still don't think it would matter. We see them a 3 times a year and live in the same town! Granted, they are all high school graduates. 

    Married to the love of my life since 2005
    TTC #1 - 
    BFP # 1: 5/2006 - m/c @ 6 weeks (natural) / EDD 1/17/2007
    BFP # 2: 7/2007 - chemical pregnancy / EDD 3/18/2008
    BFP # 3: 6/2013 - 7/9 u/s: No hb, measuring 2 weeks behind. Very high HCG#'s 7/21 u/s: No change, ruled out molar pregnancy. Completed Natural Missed M/C 7/26/2013 / EDD 2/5/2014
    TTA with Diaphragm. 
    CFNBC
    I didn't want to kiss you goodbye, that was the trouble; I wanted to kiss you goodnight. And there's a lot of difference. - Ernest Hemingway 

    Licensed foster family. No current placements. Open to adoption but that is not our goal and as such we don't have dual foster/adopt home study.
    2012-2013: Former Foster Mommy to 1 bubbly little 8 y.o. girl that has moved onto an amazing adoptive home.

  • The way you word this is so strange. Your "MIL's cousins" are also your husband's cousins. So why wouldn't you just call them that? And their kids? Also your husband's cousins.
    image
  • Thanks for the replies. My thoughts were that one (Thomas or Louisa) would be okay, but not both. Or all three... really don't think I could ever do that. Haha. My H and I joked about it, though. "Hey, cool names... we're going to use them too." Anyway, guess we'll see what happens. I fall in and out of love with names these days so it probably won't matter anyway!

     And to PP who said I worded it weird, I don't know, the whole 'first/second cousins' or 'cousin once removed' thing confuses me. The woman is my husband's mom's cousin, so that's what I said. I don't know why it's strange.

    Married: 8.5.12
    Caleb: 10.9.13
    imageimageimage
  • 5555
    10 Comments 25 Love Its First Anniversary
    member

    The children would be your husband's second cousins. Their children and your children would be third cousins to one another. 

    Evidently, I was supposed to be named Ashley, but a month before I was born, my second cousin Ashley was born. My name became one of the many 1980s variations on "Lindsay." I have never met the Ashley who was born before me and took my name, but apparently my dad liked her mother, his cousin, enough to not step on her toes. 

    I'm watching all our friends gobble up the short list of names I've loved forever, so I definitely understand your frustrations. I think if you're not going to spend a ton of time with these people and the kids aren't going to be the same age, you can get by with 1-2 first names and maybe using another as a middle name.  

    Married since July 2009.
    TTC #1 beginning in May 2014
  • I love Louisa, I don't think it's a big deal but I would probably chicken out and not use that name.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards