Baby Names

Indie billy

Lots of questions!
My FI has decided that he is picking the name haha! Luckily I don't mind his choices. We are Tess Hayden not exactly "formal" names
He likes Indie for a girl I get to pick middle names, it will be Charlotte
He also likes billy for a boy. Middle name will be Alexander I think
Do you think it would be better to choose more formal/longer versions of the first name, even if we intend on always calling them the short version, to give the child a choice later in life?
Eg. Indiana charlotte or William Alexander
And also is Indianna pronounced more like indiearna a "real name"?
Or do you prefer India or indigo I'm such a hippy! But I think of indigo as a boys name

Re: Indie billy

  • Sorry I wrote this on my phone and it has removed all of my characters and brackets!
  • I don't like Indie for a girl. The only Indie I know is Indiana Jones. I'd go with India. Also William Alexander is very nice.

    Yes, I think a longer formal first name is great because then LO can decide if he or she wants to go by the longer name or the nickname.
    Lilypie - (KNqh)
  • image LivvyKH:
    I would definitely go with William over Billy, and just call him Billy. William Alexander is a lovely name.As for Indie I wouldn't consider "Indianna" a "real" name. If I had to pick a full name, I'd go with India Charlotte. nbsp;


    This.
  • image Clarinet35:
    image LivvyKH:
    I would definitely go with William over Billy, and just call him Billy. William Alexander is a lovely name.As for Indie I wouldn't consider "Indianna" a "real" name. If I had to pick a full name, I'd go with India Charlotte. nbsp;
    This.

    ITA.  My bro is William but goes by Bill.  I still call him Billy but I'm not sure really appreciates it as a grown man lol.  I loooove India.  Indie is cut but more nickname sounding.

    image
    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • I agree with PPs. I would go with William. Billy is cute for a nick name, but doesn't stand alone very well. William Alexander is a great name.

    I would go with India for sure. Indiana is just too much, and sounds masculine to me. Probably because of Indiana jones. I really dislike Indigo. Sounds like a dog name more than a baby name. India Charlotte is very cute. 

  • William Alexander - nn. Billy

    India Charlotte -- nn. Indie

     

    Both cute and allows for them to have more mature names to use as adults if they want. 

  • Estwd2Estwd2
    5000 Comments 250 Answers 500 Love Its Third Anniversary
    member

    William - because it gives him more choices

    India - because Indiana is pretty much a boy name thanks to Indiana Jones 

    image
  • I would do William, not Billy. Billy sounds like a little kid's name.

    I think Tess Charlotte is nice.

    image image Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • image LivvyKH:
    I would definitely go with William over Billy, and just call him Billy. William Alexander is a lovely name.As for Indie I wouldn't consider "Indianna" a "real" name. If I had to pick a full name, I'd go with India Charlotte. nbsp;


    This.
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers 46808 845377924360 2036704678 n


    WIMG950372 1


  • You lost me at your FI deciding he's choosing the name. Seriously? Is he going to make all of the parenting decisions, too?

    image

    image

    image

  • To get Indie I would do maybe India or probably Indigo. I lovvveeeee Indigo. 

     I would also do an extended version of Billy.  

    image

  • I love the name India! I think that India Charlotte would be very pretty.

    And I do prefer William Alexander. Great names!

    Mr. & Mrs. - Est. 10.03.2009

    TTC #1 since 06.2011 Me-24 DH-24

    12.2011 SA = Normal

    06.2012 First visit with OB/GYN

    10.2012 Clomid 50mg + TI = BFN

    11.2012 Clomid 50mg + TI = BFN

    12.2012 Clomid 100mg + TI = BFN

    01.2013 First visit with RE

    02.2013 Clomid 150mg + TI = BFN

    03.2013 Femara 5mg + TI = BFN

    05.2013 Femara 5mg + TI = BFN

    06.2013 Femara 7.5mg + TI = BFN

    *Taking a break*  

  • image Woodsie:
    You lost me at your FI deciding he's choosing the name. Seriously? Is he going to make all of the parenting decisions, too?


    You're a moderator and THAT'S your comment?! Do you know WHY he's choosing the name and you're upset about it? Or are you just blindly insulting her situation and accusing her of being run over? I thought moderators were supposed to be neutral or help keep the peace....

    By the way OP, my dh picked our lo's name and I love it. Yours are great too and I agree with the suggestions about using William and India with those cute nicknames!
  • image Woodsie:
    You lost me at your FI deciding he's choosing the name. Seriously? Is he going to make all of the parenting decisions, too?


    It looks like he's choosing the first name and she's choosing the middle name, so they are both getting input into naming the baby.

    FWIW, I agree with everyone else, India and William for formal names and use Indie and Billy as nicknames.
    imageimageimage
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker



                               
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker


                                     

  • image Lanajax319:
    image Woodsie:
    You lost me at your FI deciding he's choosing the name. Seriously? Is he going to make all of the parenting decisions, too?
    You're a moderator and THAT'S your comment?! Do you know WHY he's choosing the name and you're upset about it? Or are you just blindly insulting her situation and accusing her of being run over? I thought moderators were supposed to be neutral or help keep the peace.... By the way OP, my dh picked our lo's name and I love it. Yours are great too and I agree with the suggestions about using William and India with those cute nicknames!

    ::shrugs:: I'm allowed to have an opinion as a moderator. My job is to help enforce the terms of use, which I have in no way violated with my post.

    OP said her FI decided he's choosing the names. In the words she used, it was a unilateral decision he made and that's not cool with me. Both parents should have a say in how their child is named, period, even if that means agreeing that one spouse will choose.

    image

    image

    image

  • image jallascalla:

    William Alexander - nn. Billy

    India Charlotte -- nn. Indie

     

    Both cute and allows for them to have more mature names to use as adults if they want. 

     

    This.  Give them the option of having an "adult" name as adults.  William Alexander and India Charlotte are both great names.

    image
    A13 April Siggy Challenge
    Lilypie Premature Baby tickers
    imageimage
  • My preference would be to give them formal names with more options as they grow.

    I like India better than Indiana for the girl name.

    I also agree that Indigo leans more boy than girl to me.

  • Indiana is a not a girl's name.  It's not even a boy's name.

    Indiana Jones isn't even named Indiana.  His name is Henry.

    The dog's name was Indiana.

    Please don't name your daughter after a fictional dog.

    image
  • image blueyedwife:
    Indiana is a not a girl's name.nbsp; It's not even a boy's name.Indiana Jones isn't even named Indiana.nbsp; His name is Henry.The dog's name was Indiana.Please don't name your daughter after a fictional dog.


    Yes

    image

    image

    image

Sign In or Register to comment.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards