We have the name Roscoe on our long list. H really loves this name, I like it quite a bit. It fits our old man name style. I have a really good association with it, as it is my oncologist's first name, and he's such sweet old guy.
On my giant name poll (http://blindyswife.surveydaddy.com/s/blindy-s-name-list) it has gotten terrible reviews. It is the most hated name on the list. My feelings aren't hurt, I promise. ;) I know my style isn't for everyone, and that's okay. (I literally lol'd at one of the comments on the poll: "This is the worst name list I've seen" haha)
I am curious to get some specific feedback on Roscoe, and what you don't like about the name. (or DO like, if that's the case.) Again, you won't hurt my feelings, so be honest.
(Oh, and whichever one of you suggested Nevaeh in my comments section... you were joking, right?) :-D