I registered at both Target and Amazon.com. After my first shower I realized that NO ONE even looked at the Amazon registry - they all shopped in-store at Target, and there was hardly anything left. So I went back to Target and added a bunch of in-store items that I kind of wanted, but not really (baby toys and such). At my second shower I got some of these trinkets and I feel like since I registered for it, I should keep it.
I really want to return some of that stuff and use it towards a breast pump and car seat base, but I feel guilty since technically these are things I requested.