Back to square one, boy name..

Toricharline

30 weeks and still cant agree. I thought we had a decision, Ren Charles, but turns out my DH has a terrible memory and doesnt recall agreeing on it at all. *sigh* 
Charles is a must, for either first or middle name, but he will not go by Charles or any nn for Charles because my DD is named Marley. We both like Thatcher, but I have a "close-ish" friend with a son named Hatcher, and also our last name is     F-ller, so is the -er ending too much?? The other name we both like is Sunny. We are still open to suggestions as well. Please help! 

bbiutmcph

What about Warren Charles? You could still use Ren as a nn. I would avoid an ER ending with your surname having that and I'm not a fan of Sunny as a given. I have a relative Santino that uses Sonny not sure if you are Italian to use that, it's probably a bit much if not.

Maybe Thaddeus instead of Thatcher