I love Jacob (family name) but it has become too popular lately. Nathan and Tyler seem 90s-ish to me so I would go for Lucas. I also have a cousin my age named Lucas and I always liked him so yeah, Lucas.
I would pick Lucas because it's closest to Luke which is my DH name and I would have picked it for our 1st DS but he said no. I'm not big on Lucas. Second choice Nathan.
Nathan is at the very top of my list right now for this LO. Very likely that will be his name unless DH somehow manages to actually find and pick out a name we both love more. I also like Jacob a lot. Lucas and Tyler are good names, just not really my style.
I have always loved the name Jacob! We are having a boy, but unfortunately, out friends/neighbors recently named their little boy Jacob, so it was off our list. I like the name Lucas too, just have bad connotations from a specific family.
Re: It's Been Awhile: Vote for a Name
Jacob is in our top 2 (Owen is our other). Lucas was bumped out by Owen.